City Council Meeting
July 30, 2020 at 12:00 PM
- 37 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: July 30, 2020
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on July 30, 2020, which served as a continuation of the previous session held on July 28, 2020. The meeting was conducted remotely, allowing the public to participate via cable, live stream, or telephone. Because public hearings for the agenda items had already taken place on July 28, no new public comment was accepted during this session. The council focused on voting on four items of unfinished business, including zoning amendments, a federal grant action plan, and the annual operating budget.
Key Decisions and Votes
The council voted on four major items during the session:
- Conditional Zoning Amendment (137 Broad Street): The council approved an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning request for properties at 135 and 137 Broad Street. This change modifies the zone from Community Business I to Community Business I/Conditional Zone to include an adjacent parcel for a new mixed-use building. The motion, moved by Councilwoman Julie Mayfield and seconded by Councilman Vijay Kapoor, passed 5-2. Councilman Brian Haynes and Councilwoman Sheneika Smith voted against the amendment.
- CDBG and HOME Funds Annual Action Plan: The council adopted a resolution authorizing the submission of the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnership Act funds Annual Action Plan for Fiscal Year 2020-21 to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. The motion, moved by Councilwoman Julie Mayfield and seconded by Councilwoman Sheneika Smith, passed unanimously (7-0).
- Conditional Rezoning (61 Innovation Drive): The council approved a request to conditionally rezone property at 61 Innovation Drive from the Commercial Industrial District to the Institutional District/Conditional Zone. This includes a Future Land Use Map change from Industrial/Manufacturing to Employment/Anchor Institution Center. The motion, moved by Councilman Vijay Kapoor and seconded by Councilman Keith Young, passed unanimously (7-0).
- Fiscal Year 2020-21 Annual Operating Budget: The council voted to adopt the annual operating budget, which allocates funding for only the first three months of operations to all departments. The motion, moved by Councilman Keith Young and seconded by Councilwoman Julie Mayfield, passed 5-2. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler and Councilman Vijay Kapoor voted against the interim budget.
Discussion Highlights
The most significant debate occurred prior to the vote on the operating budget, where several council members spoke at length regarding the public reaction to the police budget and the "defund the police" movement.
- Councilman Brian Haynes stated that he had received a banner in his yard calling for the defunding of the Asheville Police Department (APD). He reiterated his conviction for both defunding and demilitarizing the APD, explaining that "defunding" is a proactive attempt to overhaul policing without abolishing it. He stated he would vote against the three-month budget plan because it did not contain an APD hiring freeze, but he did not wish to see the full-year budget approved. He voted to support the interim budget as proposed by the City Manager.
- Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler expressed her belief that the council should adopt a fully allocated yearly budget and amend it as solutions for public safety are developed. She stated that while she hears calls for an immediate 50% cut to the APD budget, she believes the city cannot responsibly execute such a cut immediately. She argued that tying staff in knots with a three-month budget would be distracting and prevent them from working on long-term solutions. She stated, "I want them [staff] to be working on the goal of finding ways that APD can discontinue work that they don't need to be doing... If we let staff do that work now, we will have a much better product to show our community in September."
- Councilman Vijay Kapoor used his final official meeting to reflect on his time on the council. He thanked his family, colleagues, and staff, specifically praising City Manager Deborah Campbell and City Attorney Brad Branham. He apologized to the family of Derrick Lee Jr., a 12-year-old killed in 2018, stating, "A child was killed in the city on my watch, and that is my responsibility." Regarding the budget, he argued that allocating only three months of funding during a pandemic is "irresponsibly risky." He warned that passing a three-month budget would set unrealistic expectations for an immediate 50% police defunding in September, which he believed was not feasible. He urged the council to pass a full-year allocation to keep the city steady and allow the "reimagining public safety" process to work, stating, "Please, let's pass a full year allocation tonight so we can keep our city steady."
- Mayor Esther Manheimer thanked the public, council, and staff for their engagement in the budget process. She highlighted that the budget includes funding for transit, roads, parks, and economic development. She acknowledged that while the council agrees on the goal of divesting and investing in public safety, the timeline and method are points of contention. She stated that a 50% cut to the police budget by September 22 is "not realistic." She explained that her vote for the three-month budget was driven by the legal requirement to have a budget and her responsibility to ensure basic city services (water, garbage, staff pay) continued. She noted that she voted for the motion because she knew the other votes would fall in that direction, ensuring the city could continue to operate.
Follow-ups
The council explicitly stated that the budget will be revisited and returned to the council for a vote on September 22, 2020. Additionally, the City Manager’s office will continue the "reimagine public safety" process, with the goal of determining how the city structures department responsibilities and community partnerships to promote racial equity and economic inclusion.
Impact on Residents
The adoption of the three-month operating budget ensures that basic city services, including water, garbage collection, and staff pay, continue during the interim period while the council and staff work on long-term public safety solutions. The approval of the CDBG and HOME Action Plan authorizes the use of federal funds for housing and community development projects, including emergency shelter, home repair for low-income homeowners, and small business development. The zoning changes at 137 Broad Street and 61 Innovation Drive facilitate the construction of a new mixed-use building with affordable housing units and the completion of the Franklin School of Innovation campus, respectively.
Meeting Video & Transcript