City Council Meeting
August 25, 2020 at 12:00 PM
- 2 h 5 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: August 25, 2020
The Asheville City Council held a regular virtual meeting on August 25, 2020, to address a wide range of infrastructure, public safety, and land use issues. The Council voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the consent agenda, which included authorizing the City Manager to ratify a paratransit services agreement with Buncombe County, execute a contract with the Green Built Alliance for the Blue Horizons Project, and purchase two Gillig 30-foot diesel electric hybrid buses. The Council also approved ordinances changing posted speed limits along several streets and enacting a through truck prohibition along six streets. Additionally, the Council authorized contracts for the Design-Build City Hall Elevator Modernization Project, the Fulton Street Bond Sidewalk Project, and the Livingston Street and Reservoir Road resurfacing project.
In housing and land use matters, the Council passed a resolution authorizing a grant agreement with the Asheville-Buncombe Community Land Trust for $1 Million in Affordable Housing Bond dollars and $100,000 in Housing Trust Fund Donation Funds. The Council also amended Resolution No. 17-198 to change the unit goal for the Community Land Trust from 35 units to 8–10 units. A resolution was passed relating to North Carolina House Bill 1200, urging state legislators to restore the bill to its original intent of providing $100 million for rental assistance and $100 million for mortgage assistance, and calling on Governor Cooper to reenact eviction moratoriums. The Council also approved a resolution of intent to set a public hearing on September 22, 2020, to close a portion of an unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street.
The Council conducted public hearings on several land use items. The public hearing to amend the U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development 5-Year Consolidated Action Plan was continued to October 13, 2020. The public hearing to consider an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance to update open space requirements was continued to October 27, 2020. The Council voted to recess three related public hearings regarding the Tree Canopy Preservation and Enhancement Ordinance to September 8, 2020. These items included an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance establishing a new Resource Management Overlay District, an ordinance establishing a fee-in-lieu option for tree removal, and an initial zoning to apply the new Resource Management Overlay District citywide. Staff presented the proposed ordinance, which incentivizes preserving existing trees over planting new ones or paying fees. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler and Councilman Brian Haynes expressed support for the ordinance, noting broad community support.
The Council also voted unanimously to set a public hearing on September 8, 2020, to consider extending the temporary moratorium on hotel development for two months due to delays associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. The Council approved the Board of Alcoholic Beverage Control’s Travel Policy adopted January 26, 2016, and authorized the procurement of key box access equipment and security for commercial buildings for the Asheville Fire Department from sole source vendor Knox Company. The Council amended its Rules of Procedure to update local rules regarding land use and development to coincide with recent State law changes.
During the City Manager’s Report, the City Manager provided an update on the 30-60-90 Day Work Plan developed in response to the Black Asheville Demands Coalition. The update noted that the Vance monument was shrouded and the Lee monument was removed, and that conversations have been initiated to defund the Police budget by 50% using a "Defund/Divest/Invest" strategy. The City is conducting a public engagement process to determine how to defund the police budget, with facilitators selected to hold virtual and small in-person meetings. The City Attorney provided an update on the review of the Asheville Police Department’s response to recent protests. The Council also received an update on the procedure to fill the vacancy resulting from a council member's resignation and interviewed several candidates for the position.
Public commenters raised various concerns during the meeting. Regarding the consent agenda, one commenter expressed disappointment that Buncombe County decided to eliminate its subsidy for the city’s paratransit service, stating, "I'm just very disappointed that this, the County decided at this time to completely eliminate that subsidy... it doesn't feel very partnership like." Another commenter highlighted positive items on the agenda, including pedestrian safety measures and funding for the Community Land Trust, stating, "I just wanna remind folks that there's still a lot of good stuff happening at the city... I was just pleased to see all of these things on the agenda." A commenter from the Inka/Candler area asked for details on the public engagement process for the budget and how the city would communicate the urgency of rental assistance to landlords.
Regarding the Tree Canopy Ordinance, a public commenter from West Asheville supported the ordinance, arguing that it disproves claims that it would hinder affordable housing, and stated, "Asheville can have both the affordability and the sustainability that our city needs. The two priorities don't conflict. They intersect." Another commenter requested that the "fee in lieu" be scaled appropriately to replace canopy loss and asked for a race and class analysis to address the loss of trees in historic Black neighborhoods. A commenter representing a pagan religious nonprofit spoke in support of the ordinance, citing a 33% loss of tree canopy in West Asheville over the last 10 years, and asked the Council to "vote yes to adopt the Tree Canopy Protection Amendment."
During informal public comment, multiple residents raised concerns about recent police actions, including the deaths of Hannah Guffey and Jacob Biddix in custody, the shooting of Grant Dalton on a city bus, and the conduct of former officer Rondell Lance. One commenter stated, "If you're not ready to defund and abolish GCOS and APD and directly invest in our communities, you are not paying attention." Another commenter from West Asheville called for a "drastic reduction in spending on the police department," the immediate firing of Police Chief David Zak, and independent investigations into the deaths in custody and the bus shooting, stating, "There cannot be peace in a town filled with terror." A commenter from Arden described witnessing former officer Lance harass protesters and called for the "immediate removal of the police chief." Another commenter linked the budget to community values, stating, "My heart is broken. I know that my tax dollars are being used to harass my neighbors, and it has to stop," and requested an immediate hiring freeze extension.
The Council voted unanimously to enter closed session to consult with the City Attorney regarding privileged and confidential information and potential judicial action. No specific follow-up actions were explicitly agreed to by members or staff in response to public comments during the recorded portion of the meeting. The next steps for the deferred items are as stated: the HUD Five-Year Consolidated Action Plan hearing is set for October 13, 2020; the Open Space Requirements hearing is set for October 27, 2020; the Tree Canopy Preservation hearings are set for September 8, 2020; and the Hotel Development Moratorium hearing is set for September 8, 2020.
Meeting Video & Transcript