Design Review Committee – December 14, 2023
December 14, 2023 at 12:30 PM
- 1 h 14 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The City of Asheville Design Review Committee met on December 14, 2023, to review the minutes from its previous session and conduct a formal design review for a proposed hotel project in the downtown area. The meeting also included a staff presentation regarding the ongoing process to update the city’s downtown design guidelines.
Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the October 19, 2023 meeting. The primary decision of the evening was a recommendation to approve the Courtyard hotel project at 215 Haywood Street, subject to specific conditions. The vote on this recommendation was 7-1 in favor. One member voted against the project, stating that while the design was good, they did not support it because it only met minimum design guidelines without providing additional sustainable or community benefits. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented an update on the revision of the downtown design guidelines, which were originally adopted in 2009. Staff member Dave Hazard explained that a working group will be formed, including members from the Design Review Committee, Downtown Commission, and Historic Resources Commission, along with a consultant hired with a $50,000 budget to address gaps in the current documents. Hazard noted, "The resources we have... is essentially city staff, the working group... and then we have $50,000 to hire a consultant to fill in the missing pieces."
The committee then conducted a formal Level Two design review for the new six-story hotel building (80,825 sq. ft.) at 215 Haywood Street. The discussion focused on changes made since informal reviews in September and October, including the removal of a rooftop restaurant, adjustments to the ground-floor bistro entrance, parking configuration, and facade materials. During the debate, a committee member expressed frustration regarding consistency in reviewing hotels, stating, "We almost denied a project for coming... to us with the same amount [of benefits]. It seems like we need to develop some consistency." Chair Jeremy Goldstein responded to the discussion on hotel benefits by stating, "I do not believe we need to be telling them they have to go above and beyond what's required... If we want to revisit the public benefits table, that's a different thing."
Additional design critiques included comments on the building's front element, with one member noting, "It’s just a fat, flat pier on top of a spindle... It’s inconsistent with the rest of your detailing." Another member suggested, "Celebrate the pedestrian... bring attention to what hopefully is more important, which is where people enter rather than where the cars are."
Follow-ups Staff member Dave Hazard stated he would send an email to boards and commissions with a form to gauge interest in serving on the design guidelines working group. Regarding the hotel project, the committee approved the design subject to conditions that the design team must address, including exploring reworking the right-side planter walk at the bistro entrance, reducing and coordinating the vertical integration of the second-story pier width with the first-story pier width, and coordinating the second-story connection piece over the front bistro canopy and pedestrian entrance. Staff member Tony Hauser indicated he would work with the design team to determine if a green roof could be incorporated to manage stormwater. The applicant stated that mechanical equipment will be screened, noting that if the screening requires a substantial increase in the parapet height (more than one foot) or changes the building's proportions, the project may need to return for another review.
Impact This meeting established the path for updating the downtown design guidelines, which will involve a multi-agency working group and external consulting support. Additionally, the committee’s recommendation to approve the 215 Haywood Street hotel project, contingent on specific facade and stormwater improvements, moves the project forward in the development process. The conditions set by the committee aim to ensure the building’s design integrates more effectively with the pedestrian experience and surrounding streetscape.
Meeting Video & Transcript