Skip to main content

Design Review Committee – October 19, 2023

October 19, 2023 at 12:30 PM

  • 2 h 18 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Recap: October 19, 2023

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee met on October 19, 2023, to review three hotel projects located within the city’s designated design review areas, including Downtown, Riverfront, and New Hotel Overlay Zoning Districts. The committee established a quorum and proceeded with a formal review of two projects and an informal review of a third. The meeting concluded with the approval of the minutes from the September 21, 2023 meeting, unanimous votes on two project recommendations, and the adjournment of the session.

The first item on the agenda was a formal Level 2 review of the Tempo by Hilton Hotel at 22 Carter Street, a proposed six-story mixed-use building featuring 115 hotel rooms, commercial space, and structured parking. Staff and the architect presented significant design revisions, including new retail space along Carter Street, changes to the building’s massing, and a "jump lobby" concept for hotel access. Committee members debated several design elements, with particular focus on pedestrian access and the building’s north facade. Concerns were raised regarding the primary pedestrian entrance, which requires guests to navigate around a driveway rather than entering directly from the street frontage, though staff clarified that the retail entrance on the frontage line satisfies guideline requirements. Members also criticized the "dead" appearance of the North Ann Street facade, specifically the blank wall near the exit stair tower.

Following the discussion, the committee voted unanimously to approve the 22 Carter Street project as presented, subject to three specific conditions: continuing the storefront glazing on the North Ann Street facade around to the north side of the retail space; revising the site plan to create an activated, occupiable pedestrian space between the dumpster driveway and the retail space; and continuing the piers across the front in the same rhythm across the cantilever. Chair Christina Roush (formerly Booher) noted that she wanted to see these comments addressed before voting, emphasizing the need for the applicant to commit to specific changes rather than receiving them as mere suggestions.

The committee then conducted a formal Level 1 review of a hotel conversion at 19 & 25 South French Broad Avenue, which involves converting two existing single-family houses, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, into a 15-room hotel. The architect and applicant confirmed they are working with a historic consultant to ensure period-appropriate details, such as replacing non-original metal porch railings. A member raised concerns about the impact of new impervious surfaces on the local watershed, which is already stressed by nearby hotel developments, and requested that the design team explore sustainable stormwater best management practices, such as rain gardens or cisterns. The applicant agreed to consider these options. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the project, subject to the condition that the applicant direct the design team to consider stormwater best management practices as much as practicable.

The final item was an informal Level 2 review of the Courtyard Asheville hotel at 215 Haywood Street, a six-story building with 115 rooms. No vote was taken on this project. Members criticized the facade materials, noting that the brick application appeared thin and "pasted on," and suggested using more brick to create a cohesive look, particularly on the corner tower. One member remarked, "I'm just saying right now it just looks like they ran out of fondant," while another noted that the design team needed to develop rigorous rules for integrating different materials. Members also expressed concern that the entrance sequence was confusing, with pedestrians walking past bike racks to enter the lobby. Regarding accessibility, Director of Finance Tony McDowell explained that challenging grades on the sidewalk, hitting a 6% cross slope, were an existing condition that the team was dealing with without significantly pushing the building footprint back. The committee requested further design development regarding facade materials, entrance clarity, and stormwater management, including expanding green roof coverage.

No public comments were received for any of the three projects. Regarding follow-ups, the applicant for the 22 Carter Street project is expected to revise the design to incorporate the three approved conditions. For the 19 & 25 South French Broad Avenue project, the applicant’s design team is to review and incorporate sustainable stormwater management practices. For the 215 Haywood Street project, the applicant is to revise the design to address the committee’s feedback. Additionally, staff member Will Pompous agreed to email examples of green roofs and streetscape elements to the applicant for reference. The committee indicated they would likely see the applicant again next month if the design becomes formal.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches