Historic Resources Commission – December 13, 2023
December 13, 2023 at 3:59 PM
- 1 h 25 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: December 13, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) met on December 13, 2023, to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) and to receive a presentation on the city’s final Missing Middle Housing Study. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous November meeting, which passed unanimously. The commission then addressed two public hearing items involving property modifications in historic districts before moving to a staff presentation and public comment session regarding housing policy.
Key Decisions The commission voted unanimously to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness for site improvements at 5-0 Souls Crescent in the Biltmore Village Historic District. The approved project includes the installation of a pea gravel patio, screening plantings, and outdoor furniture. The COA was issued with four specific conditions: the applicant must submit a revised site plan showing landscaping along the northern edge of the patio for staff review; planting species must mature to a height sufficient to screen the patio from the street; the applicant must submit the neighboring property owner’s affidavit; and the applicant must submit details on the edging material between the pea gravel and the landscaping for staff approval.
Additionally, the commission voted unanimously to approve and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness for modifications to a non-contributing accessory structure (carriage house) at 372 Montford Avenue in the Montford Historic District. The approved modifications include new windows, doors, a covered porch, and a roof overhang. During the discussion, a commissioner noted that because the structure is non-contributing, it could be treated similarly to new construction, and affirmed that the proposed changes were congruous with the property.
Discussion Highlights: Missing Middle Housing Study A city staff member presented the final report on the city’s Missing Middle Housing Study. The presenter highlighted that the report references "historic" 45 times and aims to return to the basics of how Asheville built neighborhoods 100 years ago. When asked about affordability, the presenter clarified that while the study does not focus on low-income housing, it addresses the income group between 80 and 120 percent of the area median income, which the Bowen report identified as having the largest housing gap of over 5,600 units in the Asheville area.
During the subsequent public comment period, a public commenter expressed concern that the study’s recommendation to reduce barriers to development included reducing plantings, stating, "We want this to be a town we wanna live in. So while we need to increase density, I'm not sure that reducing plantings is a goal we should strive for." A commissioner responded by suggesting the commenter reach out directly to the presenter, whose contact information was provided, to inquire about submitting public comment through the process.
Another public commenter, identifying as a builder/contractor, noted that the study focused heavily on new construction and lacked discussion on adaptive reuse, stating, "I was just surprised to not see any adaptive reuse. Like it's all about building you know, let's build some, keep building, keep building, when we've got plenty of structures that could certainly fit the description of missing middle housing." A commissioner responded with criticism of the study, stating, "I was very disappointed that it has almost nothing to do with affordability across the board... it does not address issues with around vacation rentals." The commissioner noted there are between 3,000 and 5,000 vacation rentals in Buncombe County and added, "You cannot build your way out of the housing crisis. New construction precludes affordability." The commissioner recommended a keynote by Don Ripkema at Preservation North Carolina’s conference, which argued that existing buildings are key to solving the housing crisis.
A third public commenter raised sustainability concerns, noting that construction demolition accounts for 40 percent of landfill mass and that naturally occurring affordable housing has existed in older neighborhoods for decades. In response, a staff member stated, "I tried my best... to voice my opinion through the review of the study process. But I felt like the consultant team was kind of unwilling to really hear what we were saying... I just, and then they weren't even, for the most part, referring to the historic context... I appreciate everyone's comments for sure." The staff member added, "I think that we all know that it is in terms of how it fits into affordable housing and so I have some work to do on my end and I would say talk to our elected officials... because we have to fight this fight."
Follow-ups A staff member explicitly agreed to create a slide deck pulling statistics from Dr. Ripkema’s keynote and information on anti-displacement and preservation overlays to share with the commission and elected officials. The staff member also stated they would forward the link to Dr. Ripkema’s keynote to the HRC members.
Impact The decisions made regarding 5-0 Souls Crescent and 372 Montford Avenue allow for specific exterior modifications within historic districts, subject to the conditions set by the commission to ensure compatibility with the surrounding area. The discussion on the Missing Middle Housing Study highlighted ongoing community debate regarding the balance between increasing housing density, preserving historic character and greenery, and addressing affordability through adaptive reuse versus new construction.
Meeting Video & Transcript