Skip to main content

Historic Resources Commission – November 8, 2023

November 8, 2023 at 4:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Oct 16 meetingNext: Dec 13 meeting
  • 54 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: November 8, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on November 8, 2023, to address several items on its agenda, including the approval of previous minutes, a certificate of appropriateness hearing, a preliminary discussion on landmark designation, and updates on neighborhood standards and commission logistics. The meeting began with the review and approval of the minutes from the October meeting, which passed unanimously with all members in favor and none opposed.

The Commission voted to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) for the installation of 14 solar panels on the western-facing roof section of a property at 230 Cumberland Avenue in the Montford Historic District. This motion also passed unanimously. Following the approval of the CA, a subsequent motion was made to issue the certificate based on the findings, which also passed unanimously. Staff noted that due to the property’s elevation and structure, the panels would be largely invisible from the street, and no concerns were raised during the hearing. No public comment was received for this item.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a preliminary discussion regarding the potential local landmark designation of the Woolworth Building (now Woolworth Walk). No vote was taken on this item, and it remains in the preliminary review stage. A public commenter, the current owner of the building, spoke in support of the designation, stating, "I personally think the building needs to be preserved as it is... It is a true landmark to this town." The owner highlighted restoration efforts, including the 2001 reconstruction of the original lunch counter, and emphasized the building’s maintained integrity.

Commission members responded to the applicant’s testimony with varying perspectives on the building’s significance. A staff member explained that while the owner is not required to include the interior in the designation, the Commission generally prefers to include interior features to ensure preservation. Commissioner Annie Mcdonald noted that the building is a "late expression of Art Deco" and suggested that a comparative analysis against other Art Deco buildings in Asheville, such as the SNW or City Hall, would be needed to determine if it rises to the level of "special significance." She stated, "Comparatively we will find that it does not rise to the top as far as special significance is concerned... When you look at architecture, you’re looking [at whether] a property is representative of a style." Commissioner Sara Groce emphasized the historical importance of the site, noting, "Something important happened in this building historically for people of color in Asheville... Woolworths is known for that," and highlighted the significance of the lunch counter in the context of the civil rights movement. Chair Will Hornaday suggested exploring the building’s 1939 construction date and its fit within broader architectural trends of the late 1930s. Additionally, a staff member suggested that if the owner’s primary goal is outright preservation, a conservation easement or covenant with the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) might be a more effective tool than a local landmark designation, as it offers tax benefits and long-term protection.

The Commission also received an update on recent community engagement regarding potential amendments to design standards in a local neighborhood. Staff indicated that if the neighborhood’s interest in amending these standards formalizes, the Commission will work with the neighborhood association to form a working group or subcommittee to help define the amendments and conduct additional community engagement. Finally, the meeting covered logistics for the upcoming commission retreat, with staff asking Commissioner Christopher German to confirm his attendance by responding to a calendar invite. The meeting concluded with a unanimous motion to adjourn.

Follow-ups

  • Staff agreed to send the contact information for the preservation specialist at the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) to the Woolworth Building applicant.
  • Staff agreed to look into other local landmark designation reports for Art Deco buildings in Asheville to help the applicant understand how architectural significance is argued.
  • Staff stated that if the neighborhood’s interest in amending design standards formalizes, the Commission will work with the neighborhood association to form a working group or subcommittee and conduct additional community engagement.
  • Staff asked Commissioner Christopher German to confirm his attendance at the upcoming retreat by accepting or declining the calendar invite.

Impact These decisions and discussions impact residents by shaping the preservation and development standards within Asheville’s historic districts. The approval of the solar array at 230 Cumberland Avenue allows for renewable energy installation that is visually compatible with the Montford Historic District. The preliminary discussion on the Woolworth Building highlights the ongoing evaluation of how architectural style and historical significance are weighed in landmark designations, particularly regarding the building’s role in the civil rights movement. The potential formation of a working group for neighborhood standards indicates a continued effort to engage with local communities in defining design guidelines.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches