City Council Work Session – December 12, 2023
December 12, 2023 at 2:50 PM
- 1 h 49 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Work Session Recap: December 12, 2023
The Asheville City Council held a work session on December 12, 2023, to review the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) process and begin initial planning for a potential 2024 General Obligation (GO) Bond referendum. The session was strictly informational, with no votes taken or formal motions made. Staff and external financial consultants presented data on the city’s capital needs, debt capacity, and funding strategies to provide context for future budget decisions.
Key Discussions and Financial Context Staff outlined the city’s current capital spending, noting that it has returned to pre-2016 bond levels of approximately $20 million annually after a previous peak driven by the 2016 bond and RATTIP projects. The Budget Manager presented data from a UNC School of Government benchmarking project, indicating that Asheville’s Pavement Condition Index is lower than peer cities due to a backlog of repaving needs and higher local construction costs. Staff and the Capital Projects Director also discussed a challenging bidding environment characterized by limited contractor availability and rising costs for materials and skilled labor.
Regarding debt capacity, the Finance Director and external consultants reviewed the city’s current debt outstanding, which includes $64 million in GO bonds and $23 million in special obligation bonds. They explained the use of short-term construction loans followed by long-term bond issuance to align spending with debt service. The consultants presented three conceptual scenarios for a potential 2024 bond: a single $150 million vote in 2024, two votes of $75 million each (in 2024 and 2028), or a "steady state" approach with votes every two years. They estimated that a $150 million bond would require approximately $10 million in additional annual revenue, roughly equivalent to 5 pennies on the tax rate based on current valuations, to remain affordable within the debt model. Staff also noted new state legislation requiring specific language on the 2024 ballot regarding potential tax increases and total debt costs.
Member Statements and Policy Priorities During the session, council members raised several policy priorities and questions. One council member stated a commitment to discussing affordability for city staff in every bond conversation and ensuring bonds are backed by policy that achieves "deeply affordable, equitable, accessible housing." Another member asked if a bond could be specifically designated for "deeply affordable housing"; staff and consultants responded that while ballot language is regulated, the council can set policy on how funds are spent.
A council member requested a 3-5 year projection of wage and compensation costs to ensure the city can retain staff while discussing new tax increases. Another member suggested using a "2D presentation" matrix to show how projects align with multiple council priorities, such as transportation and affordable housing, to help the public understand the "multi-solving" nature of investments. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated, "We want to provide for you information on not just what our needs are, but the potential for us to find the revenue and funding that’s needed for us to pay for these needs." Finance Director Tony McDowell added, "We have a lot of needs out there. And one of the best ways of getting additional resources to meet those needs is through the GeoBond referendum." External consultant Doug Carter noted that Asheville’s Moody's AAA credit rating reflects that the city "plans and does like the cream of the crop."
Follow-ups and Next Steps Staff and the City Manager outlined several next steps for the coming months. The City Manager stated that an HR study is underway to establish a compensation philosophy, which will be brought back to the Policy, Finance, and HR committee for discussion. Staff confirmed they will conduct a budget survey in January, utilizing results from the National Community Survey to help hone in on priorities. Additionally, staff confirmed they are attending neighborhood meetings to inform residents of the capital planning process and will share a map of identified projects with communities. Staff and consultants will continue to refine the bond scenarios and affordability models as the budget process moves forward, with formal council actions expected in June and July 2024 if a bond is pursued.
Impact on Residents This work session provided residents with a clearer picture of the city’s infrastructure challenges and the financial mechanisms required to address them. By reviewing the debt capacity and presenting specific bond scenarios, the council is laying the groundwork for potential future tax implications. The emphasis on affordability, housing policy, and staff retention highlights the council's intent to balance capital investment with the economic realities of the community and its workforce.
Meeting Video & Transcript