City Council Meeting
December 12, 2023 at 12:00 PM
- 4 h 43 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Asheville City Council Meeting Recap: December 12, 2023
The Asheville City Council held a formal meeting on December 12, 2023, following a 3:00 p.m. worksession focused on the Fiscal Year 2025 Capital Improvement Program and General Obligation bond planning. The formal agenda included the approval of the consent agenda, the presentation of the Fiscal Year 2023 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, and a series of public hearings regarding land use and housing developments. The Council also addressed new business items related to housing policy, public art, and a request for a timeline extension from the Community Reparations Commission.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council voted on 20 items during the meeting. Most items passed unanimously, including the approval of the combined minutes from November 9 and November 14, 2023; the adoption of the Fiscal Year 2024-25 Budget Calendar; and the approval of the 2024 City Council Meeting Schedule. Unanimous approvals also included contracts for the Downtown Cleaning Contract with WNC Landscaping, LLC; a resolution to intervene in Duke Energy’s Carbon Plan Integrated Resource Plan; an interlocal agreement with Asheville City Schools; a technical budget amendment; a contract with Responder Support Services for behavioral health; a contract with TranSystems, Corp. for signal pole replacement; a contract with Young & McQueen Grading Company for stormwater improvements; an ordinance for Housing Authority parking regulation; a contract with The Car Park Group, LLC; property tax refunds; and the adoption of the revised Housing Trust Fund Policy.
Several items received non-unanimous votes. The resolution to permanently close an unopened right-of-way between Sulphur Springs Road and Lane Avenue was tabled. The continuation of consideration to conditionally rezone 2 Butler Road passed 5-1, with Sage Turner voting no. The land use incentive grant for 115 Fairview Road passed 4-3, with Kim Roney, Antanette Mosley, and Sheneika Smith voting no. The public hearing to conditionally zone 115 Fairview Road passed 5-2, with Kim Roney and Sheneika Smith voting no. The ordinance amending the Public Art and Culture Commission rules passed 6-1, with Kim Roney voting no. The resolution to sign a master agreement with Axon Enterprise, Inc. for police equipment and drone software passed 6-1, with Kim Roney voting no. Finally, the resolution to amend a Housing Trust Fund loan award for Commonwealth Development Corporation passed unanimously.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to housing policy and specific developments. Staff presented data from the Thrive Asheville report, noting that while city tools like the Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) have produced units, the data lacks racial breakdowns of tenants. Council members debated whether the current LUIG program is achieving equity and climate goals, with one member stating, "I want to support land use incentive grant as a kind of voluntary rent control... But if it's not getting to racial equity, then it's not helping me be responsible for meeting our goals." Another member asked if the Council preferred larger numbers of affordable apartments for families making $68,000 or fewer units that are more deeply affordable. Staff noted that the city is working with Enterprise Community Partners to update the Affordable Housing Plan, with draft recommendations expected in March/April 2024.
Regarding the 115 Fairview Road development, which includes 281 units, the developer proposed reserving 50% of the affordable units for Housing Authority voucher holders. The Council also discussed the Fiscal Year 2023 audit, where Finance Director Tony McDowell stated, "The audit opinion issued by Cherry-Beckert was unmodified or clean, which is the highest level of assurance that they can provide." He noted the year-end unassigned fund balance was 18.8%, exceeding the city’s 15% policy threshold. Additionally, the Chair of the Community Reparations Commission requested a timeline extension, stating, "We need more time... The data coming from the state and the data coming from the private sector is nowhere near as forthcoming."
Community Input Public comment was received on several items. Regarding the 115 Fairview Road development, a public commenter representing a pro-housing organization supported the project, arguing that preventing new homes exacerbates the gap between landowners and non-owners. Another commenter, a member of the Planning and Zoning Commission, supported apartments as transitional housing. A resident from the Stoner Road community expressed concern that the project would devastate the neighborhood due to traffic and high income requirements. A video was also submitted by a resident expressing concern over traffic congestion and pedestrian safety on Sweet Creek Road and Fairview Road.
During general public comment, multiple individuals urged the Council to adopt a draft resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza, citing international law and civilian casualties. Members did not respond to these comments. A public commenter, identifying as a member of the reparations commission, requested an extended timeline, citing staff changes and the difficulty of building community capacity. Members did not respond to this comment. Another commenter proposed the installation of acoustic cameras to ticket loud vehicles. A staff member responded by stating that the city could send the commenter information on the updated noise ordinance and that the City Attorney could send information about North Carolina law regarding camera enforcement. Finally, a public commenter presented historical voter registration data from 1900 showing a decline in Black voter registration, connecting it to the reparations process. Members did not respond to this comment.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to draft a letter to the North Carolina Local Government Commission regarding two accounting errors identified in the audit, which must be sent within 60 days. Staff also agreed to begin reporting on corrective action plans for these findings at the next Audit Committee meeting in January. Regarding the reparations timeline, the Commission Chair stated they would refine the community engagement proposal, and the Vice Mayor suggested the Commission could return in April to provide updates. A council member stated that staff would reach out to the Department of Transportation to inquire about planned improvements for the intersection mentioned in the public comment video. A staff member agreed to send a public commenter information regarding the updated noise ordinance and North Carolina laws on camera enforcement. Staff confirmed that a conversation regarding the LUIG policy is scheduled for the January 16th Housing Community Development meeting.
Impact These decisions impact residents through changes in housing supply, public safety, and city finances. The approval of the 115 Fairview Road and 2 Butler Road projects will add 560 new multi-family units to the city, including affordable housing and voucher units. The adoption of the revised Housing Trust Fund Policy aims to prioritize deeper affordability and longer affordability periods for future projects. The Axon Enterprise contract will provide the Asheville Police Department with new body-worn cameras, tasers, and drone software, a decision that drew debate over surveillance policy. The city’s financial health remains strong, with a clean audit and a fund balance above the policy minimum, providing resources for future capital projects and debt service.
Meeting Video & Transcript