Policy, Finance & HR Committee – December 12, 2023
December 12, 2023 at 10:00 AM
- 1 h 34 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Policy, Finance and HR Committee Meeting Recap: December 12, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee convened via remote meeting on December 12, 2023, to address two primary agenda items: a request for a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIGE) and a review of Water Department cost-of-service rate design. The committee also adopted the minutes from previous meetings held on October 10 and November 14.
Key Decisions The committee voted unanimously to adopt the minutes from the October 10 and November 14 meetings. Regarding the Land Use Incentive Grant request from Catalyst Capital Partners for a 281-unit apartment complex at 115 Fairview Road, a motion was made to approve the application for 18 years with a total grant of $4.56 million. The approval was contingent on reserving 29 units for voucher holders and the developer making good faith efforts to make units accessible to all qualified households. The motion passed 2-1, with Councilwoman Kim Roney voting No, and Councilwoman Maggie Ullman and Mayor Esther Mannheimer voting Aye. The committee noted that this decision would be repeated at the full City Council meeting that evening. No vote was taken on the Water Department rate design; staff stated they were seeking feedback on proposed rate structures and would bring the full package of fee changes to the committee in March 2024 for a vote.
Discussion Highlights Discussion on the Land Use Incentive Grant focused on the equity of the program, referencing recent findings from the "Thrive Asheville" report regarding racial and gender disparities in housing outcomes. Councilwoman Kim Roney explained her vote against the grant by stating, "I just wanted to name that like, it’s not just the Thrive Report. It’s years of narrative data. It’s years of folks trying to make the case that they can’t access the housing we’re building... And so I say that with appreciation for your work... and when I am not able to support the land use incentive grant because of the new information that backs up the narrative data about racial and gender disparities in our housing strategies, that that’s in general and not about this project and not about the work that you’re bringing forward."
Regarding the Water Department rates, the Finance Department and consultants from Raftelis presented a realignment of water rates to reflect the actual cost of service for residential, commercial, manufacturing, and wholesale customers. The discussion covered the financial impact of a $239 million capital improvement plan and the proposed rate increases needed to fund it. Mayor Esther Mannheimer commented on the phasing of these changes, stating, "I was holding out hope that somehow we’d keep residential rates flat for five years or something while we adjusted everyone else’s rates, but I can see that we do have disparity. We’re going to correct that..." She also noted the sensitivity required regarding wholesale customers, such as Biltmore Forest, who must answer to their own rate payers. Additionally, Councilwoman Maggie Ullman expressed concern over outdated energy standards in the grant criteria, stating, "That line for Energy Star getting 15 points. That is insanely outdated... That amount of points for public money for something that isn’t even considered a bare minimum in the industry anymore is really concerning."
Follow-ups Staff agreed to several follow-up actions. Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, agreed to run the numbers for a five-year phase-in scenario for water rates to provide additional context before the full fee package is presented in March. He also indicated that staff might return to the committee in January or February with additional information. Sasha Vertensky, Affordable Housing Officer, stated that staff are working with the consulting firm Enterprise to evaluate the entire affordable housing policy ecosystem, including the LUIGE program. She committed to adding the review of "green" or energy efficiency points to the list of items to be analyzed by Enterprise, with draft recommendations expected in March 2024 and a final plan targeted for May 2024. Additionally, a staff member indicated that the Housing Committee (HCD) will hold a deeper dive into the LUIGE review process in January.
Impact These decisions and discussions impact residents through changes in housing incentives and utility costs. The approval of the grant for the Fairview Road project, despite the dissenting vote, moves the project forward toward full Council consideration, while the ongoing review of the LUIGE program aims to address disparities in housing access. For utility customers, the committee’s engagement with the water rate structure highlights the city's effort to align rates with actual service costs to fund necessary infrastructure improvements, with further analysis on phasing options to be provided in the coming months.
Meeting Video & Transcript