Skip to main content

Policy, Finance & HR Committee – November 14, 2023

November 14, 2023 at 10:00 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Oct 10 meetingNext: Dec 12 meeting
  • 1 h 10 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee held a joint meeting with the Audit Committee on November 14, 2023, via remote/virtual format. The primary focus of the session was the presentation of the City’s Fiscal Year 2023 external audit results.

Key Decisions

No formal votes were taken on substantive policy or financial matters during this meeting. A motion was made to approve the minutes from the previous meeting; however, because this was a joint session, the motion was withdrawn. The minutes will be approved at the next regular meeting. The audit presentation itself was treated as an informational item, and the committee received the presentation and the auditors' findings without a vote.

Discussion Highlights

The discussion centered on the City’s financial health and the results of the external audit conducted by Cherry Bekaert. Finance Director Tony McDowell reported that the City received an "unmodified" or "clean" audit opinion, which he noted is the highest level of assurance. He explained that the General Fund’s unassigned fund balance ended FY 2023 at 18.8%, slightly above the City’s 15% policy threshold. McDowell attributed the drop from the previous year’s 24% primarily to the appropriation of approximately $8 million for the current budget. He stated, "We have done a really good job of managing our fund balance and keeping it between the 15 to 20% level."

Representatives from Cherry Bekaert detailed two specific accounting errors identified during the audit: one material weakness and one significant deficiency. The material weakness involved the recognition of revenue for Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (ARPA) that were previously reported as liabilities. Dan Garrity of Cherry Bekaert explained, "This is one transaction that was missed... It really just has to do with the year-end process." He recommended that the City add this to their process checklist to ensure no additional revenue is missed. The significant deficiency related to the incorrect recording of a naming rights agreement as a lease receivable/deferred inflow, which should have been recorded as an intangible asset.

Mayor Esther Banheimer commented on the effort required to achieve the clean audit, stating, "I want to thank our staff. This is a heavy lift... I think it speaks highly of Tony’s leadership as well as Becky who actually did most of the heavy lifting." She concluded by congratulating the team, noting, "You set a new bar. So we’ll look for the next clean audit. Really great work, everybody."

Follow-ups

Staff confirmed that a corrective action plan for the two audit findings has already been drafted. Staff agreed to report back to the Audit Committee at its January meeting on the status of implementing these changes. Additionally, the external auditors are scheduled to present the audit results to the full City Council on December 12, 2023. Staff indicated that the process for the next fiscal year’s audit will begin in approximately March.

Impact

This meeting provided residents with confirmation that the City’s finances are in a stable position, as evidenced by the clean audit opinion and a fund balance that remains above the City’s policy threshold. The identification and correction of the two accounting errors demonstrate the effectiveness of the new external audit firm in reviewing the City's books. The upcoming presentation to the full City Council in December will allow for broader public review of these financial results.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches