City Council Agenda Briefing – December 7, 2023
December 7, 2023 at 10:50 AM
- 1 h 29 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Agenda Briefing Recap: December 7, 2023
On December 7, 2023, the Asheville City Council held a virtual Agenda Briefing Work Session, chaired by Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore. The session served as a preview for the formal City Council meeting scheduled for December 12, 2023. During this work session, no public comment was taken. The primary purpose of the gathering was to review upcoming agenda items, discuss committee updates, and address the status of the Independent Review Committee (IRC) and the Community Reparations Commission (CRC).
Key Decisions and Agenda Adjustments The only formal action taken during the briefing was the movement of Consent Agenda Item C from the Consent Agenda to New Business. Councilmember Kim Roney requested this change because she could not support the item as drafted. City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to the move, stating, "if there's no objection from any other council members that could be easily done." No other formal votes or motions were recorded during the session, as the meeting was designated for preview and discussion rather than final decision-making.
Discussion Highlights: Upcoming December 12 Agenda Council members reviewed several items scheduled for the December 12 formal meeting, including a $286,550 contract with WNC Landscaping for Central Business District maintenance, a $70,000 grant-funded mentoring program with Asheville City Schools, and purchasing agreements with Axon Enterprise for police equipment and drone management software. Councilmember Kim Roney stated she would not support the Axon item as currently drafted, noting that the inclusion of drone software is problematic because the city lacks a public-facing drone policy. Regarding public hearings scheduled for December 12, Councilmember Sage Turner expressed concern about receiving right-of-way closure requests in a "piecemeal" manner, stating she would prefer to see a "grander picture." Councilmember Kim Roney also voiced opposition to the Land Use Incentive Grant (Luigi) request for 115 Fairview Road, stating she is "not inclined to support land use incentive grant as it's currently being used" because she believes it is not helping meet strategic goals for equitable affordable housing.
Independent Review Committee (IRC) and Emergency Management Staff provided a status update on the implementation of IRC recommendations regarding emergency management, water system operations, and communications. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody emphasized that the city is "proactively making winter weather preparations" and is "committed to following through with the responses" to the IRC recommendations. Key progress includes the hiring of a dedicated valve crew, the completion of Incident Command System training for CAPE staff, and the development of an integrated preparedness workshop plan. City Manager Deborah Campbell expressed satisfaction with the progress, stating, "I am so pleased with the work and the progress that staff is making on these [IRC] recommendations."
Community Reparations Commission (CRC) Extension The council discussed a request from the Community Reparations Commission to extend their work until December 2024. Staff recommended supporting the commission only through June 30, 2024, noting that the original resolution did not set a specific deadline and that the commission is on a "positive trajectory" to finalize recommendations by spring or summer 2024. Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore supported the extension request, stating, "I think it is reasonable... especially in light of different reports that are becoming available that will be necessary to make these commitments... I think it's important that we get it right." Councilmember Antanette Mosley expressed concern about organizational alignment, hoping the city would be "ready to support first" rather than presenting a recommendation that might conflict with the commission's goals. City Manager Deborah Campbell clarified the staff position, saying, "It's not that we're going against them, we are just suggesting that let's cross the bridge if it's necessary." Dr. Dwight Mullen, Chair of the CRC, was added to the December 12 agenda to discuss the extension directly with Council.
Follow-ups and Commitments Several staff members and the City Manager agreed to specific follow-up actions for the December 12 meeting and beyond. Transportation staff agreed to contact the applicant for the West Asheville right-of-way closure to obtain a fuller picture of the development plan and address questions about potential flag lots. Planning staff agreed to prepare a summary of changes to the 2 Butler Road rezoning request since the previous meeting. Staff committed to providing an overview of the Luigi program, Thrive Report highlights, and the status of the affordable housing plan update at the December 12 meeting, with a more robust conversation on Luigi applications planned for the January HCD meeting. Additionally, Policy and Finance staff agreed to provide information on how the state budget impacts the city's ability to incentivize living wages for contract employees, aiming to start that conversation in January. Emergency Management staff committed to providing an "elected officials guide to our emergency operations plan" and training for Council. Finally, staff committed to providing continued support to the Community Reparations Commission through June 30, 2024.
Impact on Residents This briefing provides insight into the city's approach to major upcoming decisions, particularly regarding affordable housing incentives and emergency preparedness. The discussion highlights ongoing tensions regarding the use of land use incentive grants and the city's readiness to support the Community Reparations Commission. For residents, the most immediate impacts will come from the formal votes on December 12, which include the adoption of the FY 24-25 budget calendar, the approval of police equipment purchases, and public hearings on housing developments in West Asheville and the Fairview area.
Meeting Video & Transcript