Planning and Zoning Commission – December 6, 2023
December 6, 2023 at 5:03 PM
- 1 h 48 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: December 6, 2023
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened on December 6, 2023, to address housing policy, transportation alignment, and two development applications. The meeting focused on establishing new working groups to address housing shortages and reviewing specific site plans and zoning amendments.
Key Decisions The commission approved the minutes from the October 4 and October 18, 2023 meetings. The body voted to nominate Commissioner Jared Wheatley to serve as the liaison to the Multimodal Transportation Commission, a role intended to align goals and report on issues affecting Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) changes. Additionally, the commission voted to nominate a slate of three members—Commissioner Susan Bean, Chair Kimberly Levi, and Commissioner Brenton Faircloth—to form a sub-quorum work group focused on housing policy. Regarding development applications, the commission voted to recommend approval of the Level 2 site plan for the 22 Carter Street hotel, subject to outstanding technical and design review conditions. No vote was taken on the conditional zoning amendment for 5511 Brevard Road.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented a summary of the final 155-page Missing Middle Housing Study, which covers regulatory barriers, financial modeling for attainability at 80–120% of Area Median Income, displacement risk assessments, and mitigation strategies. A staff presenter noted that simply allowing more single-family homes to be built will not move the needle enough to address the housing shortage or increase attainability. Vice Chair Geoffrey Barton emphasized that the study is proactive material rather than passive, though he encouraged staff not to focus too heavily on the location data, describing it as a snapshot in time. Chair Kimberly Levi stated that the composition of the new housing work group would initially be based on availability, provided there is diversity in membership.
For the 22 Carter Street hotel, a staff planner noted that the application spent significant time working with the design review committee, describing it as a great exchange. For the 5511 Brevard Road conditional zoning amendment, which seeks to remove a 2018 prohibition on drive-throughs for a future retail development, the applicant’s attorney argued that the original condition was based on a pre-pandemic cultural context. The attorney cited a New York Times article stating that drive-thru traffic has risen 30% from 2019 to 2022 and now accounts for two-thirds of all fast food purchases.
Community Input A public commenter, identified as the General Manager of the Town Place Suites hotel located on the site, spoke in support of the 5511 Brevard Road project. The commenter stated that the proposed development would "tremendously help" their hotel and the surrounding area, which they described as currently lacking walkability and activity. Members did not respond to this comment. No public comments were received for the 22 Carter Street hotel.
Follow-ups Commissioner Wheatley accepted the nomination to serve as the liaison to the Multimodal Transportation Commission. Commissioner Bean, Chair Levi, and Commissioner Faircloth accepted roles on the new housing policy work group, with staff indicating they would work with this group to refine potential proposals. Staff stated they would provide the full renter survey data as an addendum to the Missing Middle Housing Study and indicated they would present the study to City Council in early January for guidance. Regarding the 5511 Brevard Road project, the applicant agreed to provide a pedestrian connection (sidewalk) between the existing hotel and the new building and to improve the crosswalk at the main entrance to a high-visibility standard. The applicant stated they would use their "best efforts" to work with staff on reconfiguring drive aisles to minimize pedestrian conflicts. Staff agreed to look into the status of the Buncombe County greenway easement condition.
Impact These decisions establish a formal mechanism for the Planning and Zoning Commission to coordinate with the Multimodal Transportation Commission and create a dedicated group to research housing policy within the UDO. The recommendation to approve the 22 Carter Street hotel site plan moves that project forward, subject to final technical and design reviews. The discussion on the 5511 Brevard Road amendment highlights ongoing debates regarding drive-through regulations in response to changing consumer habits, though no final decision was made on that item.
Meeting Video & Transcript