Planning and Zoning Commission – October 18, 2023
October 18, 2023 at 5:07 PM
- 54 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On October 18, 2023, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a special meeting to review a request to conditionally rezone the property at 30 Buchanan Place, known as McCormick Field, from the Institutional zone to the Institutional-Conditional zone (CZ). The property is owned by the City and serves as the home for the Asheville Tourists minor league baseball team. The agenda focused on a major renovation project that includes new clubhouse buildings, enhanced outdoor seating, and an expanded concourse. Because the scale and value of the renovation require full compliance with zoning regulations, the Commission reviewed specific technical modifications necessary to accommodate the project within the current zoning framework.
Key Decisions
The Commission voted to approve the conditional zoning request for the property at 30 Buchanan Place. The motion, which was seconded, passed unanimously with a 6-0 vote. The approval found the request reasonable, in the public interest, consistent with the comprehensive plan, and meeting community development needs. Following the approval, a motion was made to adjourn the meeting, which was seconded, and the meeting was closed.
Discussion Highlights
Staff presented the proposal, noting that the current Institutional zoning does not allow for the specific technical modifications needed for the renovation. Key modifications discussed included raising the maximum building height to 60 feet in areas near residential zones, eliminating standard building setbacks, reducing landscape buffer requirements, and reducing on-site parking from 1,000 spaces to 34 spaces in favor of an off-site traffic control plan. Will Palmquist of Planning and Design stated that staff recommends approval of the proposed conditional zoning request along with the attached exhibit E project conditions.
During the discussion, a Commissioner expressed concern about the aesthetic impact of the renovation, stating, "I really wish there was something a little more than a... three lines on each one of these elevations with materials to match. Because when I look at the front of McCormick Field, all I see is brick and it's a giant brick wall. And I'm hoping that this is not just going to be a giant brick box." Another Commissioner encouraged the city to rethink the design of the upper retaining wall, stating, "I would highly encourage the city to rethink not vegetating the upper wall as a way to put their sustainability mouth there... and vegetatively screen that wall."
The Commission also addressed infrastructure coordination. A Commissioner asked about the "Town Branch Greenway" from the 2013 Greenway Master Plan, noting it was not identified on the site plan. Dustin Clemens, Capital Projects Program Manager, explained that the "Greenway Connectors" project is being coordinated with the McCormick Field design, stating, "We are coordinating the design of that [Greenway Connectors] with the design of this McCormick Field project as well. So we've shared the CAD drawings between the two plans, and we're going to try to coordinate those as closely as we can." Regarding traffic at the Biltmore and Buchanan intersection, a City staff member noted that the Tourists began placing a person at the corner in August to direct pedestrians and stated, "We can add an exit section pretty easily before Tuesday" to the parking plan.
Community Input
Although no members of the public were present to speak during the official comment period, the Commission discussed written comments received from residents living along Hunt Hill Place. Residents expressed concern about traffic congestion and the use of off-site parking in residential areas and public parks. A Commissioner addressed these concerns, noting that similar projects, such as downtown hotels, have previously used off-site parking not included in the CZ site. The Commissioner emphasized that the project is in an urban location and that existing tools, such as the traffic management plan and noise ordinances, are in place to mitigate impacts, stating, "I just wanted to make sure that anyone that was listening or listened later that had made these public comments felt like those had gotten addressed."
A resident comment also raised concerns about trash transport, specifically whether it would require driving through a residential neighborhood at night. Chris Corral, Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities Director, clarified that the current operating procedure involves loading trash onto a gator or pickup truck and driving up the existing service road to the dumpsters. He noted that the renovation will add power to the site, allowing for a compactor, which will reduce the frequency of trash truck visits.
Follow-ups
The Commission and staff agreed to revise the language in Condition 7 of the project conditions by removing the word "generally" from the phrase "generally adhere to the traffic control and parking plan." A staff member confirmed that removing "generally adhere" to the parking plan would not be an issue, as the plan itself allows for flexibility for smaller events.
Additionally, the Commission and staff discussed adding a condition for vegetative screening on the upper interior-facing retaining wall. A staff member stated, "We would love to explore it... But to make it a condition and say we must do that, I think it's just at this point of the project, we don't know how we would be able to agree to that." Consequently, the Commission agreed to phrase the condition as "to the extent feasible" or "to the extent practical," allowing the project team to determine the specific design during the design phase. Finally, the Commission suggested adding a condition to the CZ ordinance requiring coordination with the Greenway Connectors project, to which a City staff member responded, "From the applicant's perspective, I wouldn't object to that condition at all."
Impact
This decision allows the City to proceed with the major renovation of McCormick Field, which includes significant changes to the stadium's infrastructure, such as increased building heights and reduced parking requirements. The approval of the conditional zoning, along with the agreed-upon revisions to the project conditions regarding parking language, retaining wall vegetation, and greenway coordination, establishes the regulatory framework for the construction and operation of the renovated facility.
Meeting Video & Transcript