Skip to main content

Urban Forestry Commission – December 5, 2023

December 5, 2023 at 1:04 PM

  • 2 h 35 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: December 5, 2023

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on December 5, 2023, to address urban forestry operations, policy updates, and commission governance. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of alternative compliance requests, public comment procedures for 2024, and updates from the Policy, Enforcement, and Urban Forest Master Plan working groups. The meeting also covered the transition of the Tree Review Committee (TRC) volunteer representative role, the scheduling of the 2024 annual retreat, and the nomination of 2024 officers.

Key Decisions The Commission approved the November 2023 minutes as amended to include a missing member’s name, with all voting members voting "Aye." A motion to approve an alternative compliance request for a downtown property at 34 South Lexington Avenue also passed unanimously. Regarding the 2024 annual retreat, the Commission reached a consensus to hold the event at the Asheville Botanical Gardens on Thursday, January 25, 2024, from 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM. The agenda will include a one-hour presentation by the Knoxville Trees team to allow for questions and answers. Finally, a motion to re-elect the current Chair as Chair and Zoe Hoyle as Vice Chair for 2024 was seconded and passed unanimously. The meeting was adjourned by consensus.

Discussion Highlights Staff presented updates on urban forestry operations, including a discussion on proposed amendments to landscaping standards (Chapter 711.3) and feedback on the Missing Middle Housing report. Staff member Vidilla Savicka noted that the new standards are a "huge game changer" for the city, warning that without proper oversight, trees are often planted in compacted soil surrounded by concrete. City Arborist Mark Foster expressed concern that many large trees are coming down because approvals are often finalized before staff can intervene.

Significant remarks were made regarding the departure of long-serving members. Sharon Sumrall, the departing TRC volunteer representative, warned that developers frequently request relief from landscaping standards, such as property line buffers, and noted that the city is losing "massive amounts of tree canopy" due to development. She urged the committee to ensure someone steps in to read and understand proposed ordinance changes to maintain an informed position. Chair Patrick Gilbert thanked Sumrall for her five years of service, stating, "We all have an unlimited debt of gratitude to you for all your work you've done on the TRC." He expressed confidence that Keith, the incoming representative, would "pick up that baton."

Cecil, a departing Commission member, reflected on his 14 years with the body, noting that progress is "agonizingly slow" and that the commission is still discussing the recommended species list, a topic from his first meeting in 2010. He highlighted enforcement as an "extreme problem," asking, "Why shouldn't we know what the fine is when you cut down a tree above six inches DBH?" Chair Gilbert responded by urging Cecil and Sumrall to "not be strangers and to show up any time at any of our meetings."

Community Input A written comment regarding tree removal and pruning at the Municipal Golf Course was read into the record. The Chair noted that the city had closed the chapter on that specific issue. During the public comment period, a Commission member asked for an update on remediation for trees damaged by a previous contractor. Staff member Mark Foster stated that a local company had performed the work and he was unaware of remaining tasks. The member expressed regret that the number of trees remediated was small compared to the number damaged. Another member apologized for a delayed response to a resident’s email regarding pathways built under critical root zones and asked where the plans were posted for review. A third member commented that paving over tree roots causes damage and noted that the contractor who did the work should have faced repercussions, which he believed did not happen.

Follow-Ups Staff member Vidilla Savicka agreed to add a note to the working draft of the landscaping ordinance regarding the possibility of "planting in lieu" for alternative compliance cases where site space is insufficient. She also agreed to investigate whether other North Carolina cities or counties have permit requirements for boundary trees and to incorporate feedback from the Commission and the public into the Missing Middle Housing report before the end of the year. Staff agreed to work with the Asheville Botanical Gardens to make arrangements for the annual retreat on January 25, 2024. The Chair and Joey will work on the retreat agenda and share it with the committee.

Commission members Zoe Hoyle and Patrick Gilbert agreed to review existing applications and make recommendations to the City Council for the two current vacancies on the Commission by December 29, 2024. The Chair requested that any working group members who have not yet submitted their annual updates do so within the next week or two to assist in drafting the report to the City Council. Additionally, the Chair will draft language for plaques honoring four departing members (Cecil, Sharon Sumrall, Stephen Hendricks, and Dawn Chavez) and share it with commission members. He asked members to share thoughts via email regarding where the trees should be planted, expressing a preference for a "very public place where there's a lot of traffic." Eric Bradford of Asheville Greenworks agreed to donate the trees. The Chair and Zoe Hoyle will also coordinate dates for an informal holiday gathering.

Impact These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission's focus on balancing development with the preservation of Asheville’s urban forest. The approval of the landscaping standard amendments and the alternative compliance request reflects ongoing efforts to manage tree canopy loss in a growing city. The transition of key volunteer and member roles, along with the commitment to memorialize departing members with trees in public spaces, underscores the long-term dedication of community members to urban forestry. The upcoming retreat and the continued work on the Urban Forest Master Plan and enforcement issues will shape the city's approach to tree management in the coming year.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches