Skip to main content
  • 2 h 6 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: November 7, 2023

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on November 7, 2023, to review staff reports, discuss ongoing projects, and address legislative updates. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the October 2023 meeting, which passed unanimously via roll call vote. No public comments were received during the designated public comment period.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Patton Avenue Street Project, a Community Development Block Grant-funded initiative focused on ADA compliance and tree health. Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager, presented design options including interconnected tree pits, suspended sidewalks, and tree grates. The discussion centered on the trade-offs between soil compaction in high-traffic areas, the cost and durability of suspended paving systems, and ADA requirements. The commission also debated the selection of appropriate tree species for the north and south sides of the street, considering factors such as truck interference and available soil volume.

Staff provided updates on several key areas. Keith Aiken, City Urban Forester, reported on the Inflation Reduction Act regranting, fee-in-lieu policy, and the Request for Proposals (RFP) for the urban forest master plan. Mark Foster, City Arborist, discussed routine tree care, including watering newly planted trees due to dry conditions. Nancy Watfern, Zoning Supervisor, clarified that assessed but unpaid fees for the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance are typically due before permit issuance and can fluctuate as projects are amended.

The commission reviewed updates from its working groups. Ed Macy, chair of the Policy Working Group, reported that revisions to landscape standards are nearly complete, pending legal review. Zoe Hoyle, chair of the Urban Forest Master Plan & Fee-in-Lieu Working Group, discussed the RFP process, noting that commission members offered to help draft or edit the document to expedite it. Karen Macneil, chair of the Appropriate Species List Working Group, discussed finalizing the list, including a proposal for a cover letter emphasizing native species. Cecil Bothwell and Karen Macneil, chairs of the Enforcement Working Group, expressed frustration with the city’s enforcement efforts regarding illegal tree removal. In response, Keith Aiken explained that while fines are issued, the process requires significant field inventory work to document damage or removal.

Regarding legislative matters, the commission discussed citizen petitions for flag lot and cottage cluster amendments under the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). With City Council action postponed until January 23, the commission reached a consensus to establish a process ensuring urban foresters are involved in UDO amendments that impact the tree canopy. Additionally, the commission voted unanimously to meet in person for the coming year, with a recommendation that the City Council consider a hybrid option if available.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Ed Macy, Chardin Detrich, and Sharon Sumrall agreed to develop recommendations for tree species and planting methods for the Patton Avenue project to present at the December meeting. Keith Aiken agreed to provide the commission with information on the RFP process to assist in drafting. The chair and Keith Aiken agreed to schedule a meeting with planning staff to discuss involving urban foresters in UDO text amendments. The Enforcement Working Group agreed to meet with city staff in zoning enforcement and the legal department to discuss enforcement issues and potential fine structures. Additionally, Sharon Sumrall, Keith Aiken, and the chair agreed to meet to discuss the transition of the Technical Review Committee representative role, and working group chairs were asked to send brief summaries of their year’s work by early December for the annual report to City Council.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches