Skip to main content

Reparations Commission – December 4, 2023

December 4, 2023 at 5:51 PM

  • 2 h 8 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Reparations Commission convened on December 4, 2023, to review recent progress and discuss joint recommendations for education and economic development. The meeting focused on clarifying the Commission’s role in the budgeting process, updating members on staff support extensions, and presenting a unified proposal for community resource hubs.

Key Decisions

The Commission’s primary formal action was the approval of the minutes from the November 6, 2023 meeting. A motion to accept these minutes was made and seconded by C.C. Weston, passing unanimously via voice vote. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, seconded by Joyce Harrison, which also passed via voice vote with all members in favor. No other formal votes or binding decisions were recorded during the session.

Discussion Highlights

Staff provided several critical clarifications regarding the Commission’s authority and resources. A staff member emphasized that the final decision on funding for reparations projects rests exclusively with the governing bodies—the City Council and the Board of County Commissioners—rather than the Commission itself. Regarding staffing, a staff member confirmed that the County has agreed to continue current levels of staff support until June 30, 2024, stating that it is feasible for the Commission to reach its recommendations to the governing bodies by that deadline.

The Education and Economic Development Impact Focus Areas (IFAs) presented a joint proposal centered on a "Community Education and Resource Campus" and "Economic Development Hubs." Dr. Maris Lavender, the Education IFA Facilitator, described the campus as a "one-stop shop" where needs can be met in a co-located setting, noting it is a direct response to the harm caused by urban renewal and the displacement of Black people in the community. Tara Brown, representing the Economic Development IFA, stated that the group has changed its recommendation to provide each legacy neighborhood with $250,000 in grants toward their community goals. The presentation included examples from Portland, Oregon, and Raleigh, North Carolina, to illustrate these overlapping goals of workforce development and wealth building. Additionally, a Commission member expressed the importance of the Commission representing itself directly to governing bodies, stating, "I just think the narrative needs to be clear... I think it's imperative for us to have that voice in the conversation."

Community Input

Three members of the public signed up to speak during the public comment period. One commenter argued that reparations in Asheville and Buncombe County should focus specifically on Black people who are descendants of American slaves, rather than broader categories like BIPOC or Black immigrants. A second commenter, a local business owner, expressed excitement about the Education Resource Campus idea and offered their services for personal productivity and cybersecurity training to Commission members or staff. A third commenter urged the Commission to focus on the "root of the problem" in public housing neighborhoods like Mumford and Hillcrest, suggesting the use of existing neighborhood recreation centers as resource hubs and calling for the removal of officials who perpetuate systemic oppression. Members did not respond to any of these comments.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to check with their executive staff regarding adding the Commission as a formal agenda item, rather than just a public comment slot, for the next Buncombe County Commissioners and Asheville City Council meetings, with a commitment to provide an answer to the Commission. The facilitator stated they would continue scheduling one-on-one pulse check conversations with each Commissioner and would present a full report of these check-ins to the group. Additionally, staff requested that Commission members who received an email regarding W-9 forms submit them as soon as possible.

Impact

This meeting clarified the procedural boundaries of the Reparations Commission, confirming that while the Commission develops recommendations, the City Council and County Commissioners hold the final authority on funding. The extension of staff support through June 30, 2024, provides a defined timeline for the Commission to finalize its recommendations, including the integration of the "Cease to Harm" audit. The joint proposal for a Community Education and Resource Campus and targeted economic development grants represents a significant step in the Commission’s work to address the legacy of urban renewal and displacement in the community.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches