Reparations Commission – November 6, 2023
November 6, 2023 at 5:54 PM
- 2 h 19 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On November 6, 2023, the City of Asheville Reparations Commission convened to review project management updates, receive reports from its Impact Focus Areas (IFAs), and discuss a timeline extension. The meeting began with a moment of silence to honor Commissioner Bernard Oliphant, who passed away that week. The Commission also reviewed and corrected the minutes from the October 16, 2023 meeting to clarify who made motions and seconds.
Key Decisions
The Commission approved the corrected minutes from the October 16, 2023 meeting via voice vote. A motion was made by Dee Williams and seconded by Cece Weston, and the motion passed. No vote was taken on the proposed resolution to extend the Commission’s timeline to December 2024. Instead, staff explained that City Council and the Buncombe County Board of Commissioners require a written justification for the extension. Staff confirmed they would take the resolution as written to both governing bodies, and a question regarding the justification was added to the post-meeting survey. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn.
Discussion Highlights
Brenda Mills, Director of Equity and Inclusion for the City of Asheville, and Dr. Noriel Armstrong, Chief Equity Human Rights Officer for Buncombe County, presented updates on the project management plan. Renisha Crawford of Trauma Informed Institute LLC, the new facilitator, outlined a process where each member is called by name for 1–2 minutes of comment per agenda item to ensure equitable participation. Crawford noted the Commission is in the "storming" phase of group dynamics, stating, "My job as facilitator is to help us get to the norming phase... This storming phase that we're in is absolutely normal."
The Commission received reports from its five IFAs regarding their current recommendations and feedback from city and county staff. The Criminal Justice IFA is working on six buckets of recommendations, including policing, training, and the school-to-prison pipeline. The Economic Development IFA proposed creating a Black economic development center, $250,000 grants for legacy neighborhoods, and grants for Black-owned businesses. The Education IFA presented eight recommendations, including Black teacher retention and a community education resource campus. The Health and Wellness IFA focused on access to BIPOC medical personnel, while the Housing IFA is working on land acquisition programs.
During the discussion on the timeline extension, Commissioner Dee Williams emphasized the need for deliverables, stating, "People don't respect you when you don't deliver programs and budgets... This is a business transaction. Nothing more, nothing less." Commissioner Keith Young urged the group to be proactive, saying, "Don't be afraid to run off the plantation and find freedom. Do not be the slave." Commissioner Dr. Dwight Mullins suggested considering a proposal specifically aimed at the youth for the full inclusion of the next generation. Commissioner Tiffany Debelow raised concerns about the language of the recommendations, asking, "Are we ready for that if necessary?" The Chair concluded the meeting by reviewing the objectives, stating that three of the four objectives were "more than adequately filled," while the fourth was "partially filled" because resolutions would be submitted to the city and county.
Community Input
A public commenter shared research on the history of white supremacy in Asheville’s municipal government, including the 1900 literacy test referendum and a list of 90 local officials who participated in white supremacist activities. He offered to meet with the Commission to discuss this history, but no member or staff member responded directly to the content of his research. Another public commenter, representing the Asheville citywide Black Student Union, asked the Commission to explore ways for youth to facilitate dialogue and invited commissioners to a meeting. No member or staff member responded directly to this request.
Follow-ups
Renisha Crawford stated she will reach out individually to each commissioner for 15–20 minute check-in conversations over the next month. Staff confirmed they will submit the timeline extension resolution to City Council and the Board of Commissioners. Brenda Mills stated that staff are open to helping IFAs reword recommendations to ensure language aligns with final report requirements. The Criminal Justice IFA will meet on Wednesday to discuss city/county feedback, the Housing IFA will meet next Tuesday to discuss feedback, and the Education IFA meets every other Tuesday with the next meeting scheduled for the following day at the YWCA.
Impact
This meeting marked a transition in the Commission’s workflow, moving from initial formation to the refinement of specific policy recommendations. By establishing a new facilitation process and receiving detailed reports from the IFAs, the Commission is preparing to present refined recommendations to the full body in December 2023, January 2024, and February 2024. The discussion on the timeline extension highlights the ongoing need for the Commission to justify its progress to the City Council and Buncombe County Board of Commissioners, ensuring that the final report meets the requirements of both governing bodies.
Meeting Video & Transcript