Skip to main content

Equity & Engagement Committee – November 30, 2023

November 30, 2023 at 10:59 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Oct 17 meetingNext: Dec 15 meeting
  • 1 h 44 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville’s Equity and Engagement Committee met on November 30, 2023, to review several key initiatives related to community engagement, equity, and city governance. The agenda included updates on the ARPA Community Engagement Academy, the Strategic Partnership Grant program, the Community Reparations Commission, the Racial Equity Action Plan, and research regarding accommodations and compensation for city boards and commissions.

Key Decisions

The committee took two formal votes during the meeting. First, the committee approved the minutes from the October 17, 2023 meeting. A roll call vote was recorded with Councilwoman Roney, Councilwoman Turner, and Chair Smith all voting in favor, and the motion carried. Second, the committee voted to recommend that staff bring forward potential recommendations for increasing available strategic partnership funds in the current budget cycle. This motion, moved by Councilwoman Roney and seconded by Councilwoman Turner, also passed with aye votes from Councilwoman Roney, Councilwoman Turner, and Chair Smith.

Discussion Highlights

Staff provided a progress report on the "Asheville Academy," a component of the city’s ARPA Inclusive and Accessible Government project. Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, outlined a plan for two cohorts of 12 participants who will receive $500 stipends and join a paid pool of community champions. She stated, "The vision is that all community members feel inspired to work in or with local government... The goal is to improve access to decision making, minimize engagement fatigue, and to develop a pool of paid ambassadors and community champions."

Regarding the Strategic Partnership Grant Round Four, which focuses on closing opportunity gaps for school-aged children from low-to-moderate income households, staff presented evaluation criteria and a timeline with applications opening on December 15, 2023. Councilwoman Sage Turner commented on a process change allowing applicants to practice presentations, noting, "I just think that's really helpful both for the fluidity of the presentations, but also for the applicant... They can practice and get it right and send us their best take. Remove some stress."

The committee also reviewed the status of the Community Reparations Commission (CRC), including a request for a term extension and the status of the "Cease to Harm" audit. Councilwoman Kim Roney noted, "One of the things that I've been hearing as a common thread in the ask for extension is that it takes time to get the data to make the recommendations... I just wanted to not forget to name that that's what I'm hearing." Additionally, the committee received a presentation on the completion of the city’s new racial equity action plan for the current fiscal year, developed in collaboration with all city departments and the Government Alliance on Race and Equity (GEAR).

In a final presentation, departing staff member Elena Schmidt shared the Policy Equity Analysis Team’s research into barriers to participation on city boards and commissions, including findings on compensation models in other jurisdictions. Councilwoman Kim Roney highlighted a concern raised by a HIAC member regarding the necessity of compensation: "If we don't find a way to compensate people for bringing their professional and lived experience to the table, we're just missing having a whole conversation because we're missing the resources at the table that folks can bring that maybe aren't compensated to be there while others are in a way."

Follow-ups

Staff member Rachel Wood agreed to work with the finance department between the current meeting and the January meeting to identify potential sources for additional funds or a mid-year appropriation for the Strategic Partnership Grant. She stated, "What I can do between now and our January meeting, work with the finance department, they can come forward with some ideas and then they can also have a companion presentation that would go to the policy finance and HR committee."

Regarding the Community Engagement Academy, Dawa Hitch indicated that the application process is expected to open towards the end of December or in January, pending the finalization of the contract with the selected consultants, Finley House Global. For the boards and commissions research, Rachel Wood stated that the next step is to work with current advisory board members to get feedback on what would be most workable for reducing barriers to participation, with formal recommendations planned for late spring 2024. Additionally, Brenda Mills, Director of Equity and Inclusion, stated that the city will advertise for the vacancy left by a deceased commission member and bring the two existing alternates to the Boards and Commissions Committee for consideration to fill the spot.

Impact

These discussions highlight the city’s ongoing efforts to diversify participation in local government and address systemic inequities. The approval of increased funding recommendations for the Strategic Partnership Grant aims to better support educational and resource gaps for children in low-to-moderate income households. The development of the paid community champion pool through the ARPA Academy seeks to reduce engagement fatigue and broaden access to decision-making processes. Furthermore, the research into board and commission compensation addresses structural barriers that prevent individuals from contributing their professional and lived experiences to city governance.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches