Equity & Engagement Committee – October 17, 2023
October 17, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The Equity and Engagement Committee of the City of Asheville convened on October 17, 2023, to review the final 2023 disparity study and receive updates on the Community Reparations Commission. The committee focused on the legal basis for extending the city’s race- and gender-conscious contracting policies and the ongoing work of the reparations commission, including its extended timeline and staffing changes.
Key Decisions
The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the October 13, 2023 meeting. Additionally, the committee voted unanimously to recommend that the City Council accept the 2023 disparity study as the legal basis for a compelling governmental interest in ongoing marketplace discrimination. This recommendation includes extending the race- and gender-conscious measures of the Asheville Business Inclusion Policy for an additional five-year period. This action is a committee recommendation; the final decision rests with the City Council, which is scheduled to take action on October 24.
Discussion Highlights
The committee reviewed the final disparity study conducted by Miller 3 Consulting, which found statistically significant underutilization of minority- and women-owned businesses (MWBEs) in city contracting. The study identified qualitative barriers, including a perception of lack of transparency and trust in the procurement process. Dave Miller of Miller 3 Consulting stated that race-conscious and race-neutral initiatives must work in parallel to achieve a fair, open, and transparent operation. In response, Chair Shanika Smith expressed excitement about tailoring outreach to help businesses prepare for bidding opportunities well in advance. Councilwoman Kim Roney noted that the current key takeaways did not clearly indicate how the city would engage with and learn from those who have already navigated these processes.
Staff provided an update on the Community Reparations Commission, noting that the commission’s data team is approximately 80% complete with data requests. The commission voted to extend its work period from April 2024 to December 2024, and staff are currently working with the commission to define the scope of work for this extended period. Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood noted that Christine Edwards is transitioning to a more administrative role effective November, and the city is actively recruiting for a successor to Brenda Mills, Director of Equity and Inclusion, while utilizing cross-departmental staff to maintain project momentum.
Follow-ups
Nikki Reed, Director of Community and Economic Development, agreed to follow up with Carl Harris Construction Services to gather specific feedback on how their partnership is helping MWBEs connect with city contracts. Rachel Wood agreed to suggest to the Community Reparations Commission that their Economic Development Impact Focus Area representatives attend the next disparity study presentation by Miller 3 Consulting to provide immediate feedback on overlapping recommendations. Staff also agreed to work with the Community Reparations Commission to define the scope of work for the extended timeline and to present that justification to the City Council.
Impact
This meeting establishes the committee’s formal recommendation to extend the city’s business inclusion policies, which is critical for maintaining legal protections for MWBEs in city contracting as the current policy expires on November 1, 2023. The extension of the Community Reparations Commission’s timeline through December 2024 allows for continued data collection and analysis regarding local impacts, while the hiring of a new Business Inclusion Manager and the integration of cross-departmental resources aim to sustain progress on equity initiatives despite staff transitions.
Meeting Video & Transcript