Affordable Housing Advisory Committee – November 2, 2023
November 2, 2023 at 9:36 AM
- 1 h 42 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) of the City of Asheville held a meeting on November 2, 2023. The session focused on reviewing draft policy recommendations, discussing the status of ongoing housing studies, and planning for upcoming work sessions.
Key Decisions
The committee approved the October minutes by unanimous vote. Regarding the Housing Trust Fund (HTF) policy, the committee voted to advance draft recommendations to the Housing and Community Development Committee. This motion included an amendment directing staff to consider incorporating existing energy efficiency standards into the scoring criteria; the motion, as amended, passed unanimously. Additionally, the committee noted that with the departure of co-chair Margie Bukowski, Chair Andy Barnett would serve as the sole chair, treating this as a natural transition without a formal vote to change the title.
Discussion Highlights
Chair Andy Barnett introduced new committee members Rita Lee, Jane Christen, and Stuart Zitin, along with new staff member Hunter Spitzer. Vigella Savica from the Planning Department presented the status of the "Missing Middle Housing Study," which examines regulatory barriers to mid-density housing in single-family zones and includes a displacement risk assessment. Savica stated, "We're not, there's lots of ways to create more housing... That's not missing middle housing. That would undermine the feeling of community." The final report is expected in early December, with a presentation to City Council planned for January and public engagement in the spring.
The committee reviewed draft HTF policy recommendations, which include clarifying that direct grants are not eligible uses due to state statute, creating equivalent scoring points for homeownership projects using down payment assistance, weighting the number of affordable units more heavily, adding off-site infrastructure development as an eligible use, and updating fair housing language to protect against source-of-income discrimination. Committee members also shared perspectives on housing affordability; Stuart Zitin noted, "In my native community of Oakley, the last affordable bastion in the city, in July there was a house listed for $950,000 and it sold for a million. And that's very disturbing." Rita Lee added, "Just because we cannot afford a million dollar home doesn't mean that we should be short-ended on the property or wherever we live... We need to be included in the process, but we also need to be included in having a great lifestyle here also." Scott Adams commented, "I think we need to be making incremental changes, but the reality that we live in is we're a car dependent culture and we got to respect that."
Staff provided updates on the Affordable Housing Plan, new hires in the Housing and Community Development (HCD) department, and specific projects including 319 Biltmore Road and a potential redevelopment plan for city-owned properties like Deaverview. A staff member noted, "We're all working furiously and a little overwhelmed, but we did a stakeholder analysis... and had a great conversation." Chair Andy Barnett explained the committee's role, stating, "We work with the Housing and Community Development Committee of City Council to forward our recommendations to the full city council."
Community Input
During public comment on the HTF recommendations, a public commenter representing Asheville Habitat for Humanity expressed support for policies preventing source-of-income discrimination, noting that 965 housing vouchers in Buncombe County go unused annually. Another public commenter, a resident of Maple Crest and community health worker, shared their lived experience in public housing and supported the policies prohibiting source-of-income discrimination. A public commenter from Green Built Alliance requested that energy efficiency and green building be included in the scoring system, noting that current points are insufficient. In response, a staff member confirmed that energy efficiency is currently in the existing scoring criteria but noted the committee’s recommendations were driven by community surveys focused on affordability. A committee member suggested that staff consider the energy efficiency points in their analysis, which led to the amendment included in the vote. After the vote, a public commenter from Green Built Alliance reiterated support for the energy efficiency amendment and offered technical assistance, while another public commenter emphasized that low-income homeowners deserve comfort, health, and safety considerations.
Follow-ups
Staff agreed to present the AHAC’s Housing Trust Fund recommendations to the Housing and Community Development Committee on November 27. Staff will also conduct further analysis on the technical impacts of the new HTF scoring criteria, including looking at past projects and energy efficiency, and prepare a fuller update on city property redevelopment, including Deaverview, for the December retreat. Additionally, staff will share an orientation folder with new members and the full committee. The committee will hold a work session/retreat on December 7 from 9:00 AM to 1:00 PM to draft annual recommendations for City Council’s February work session, create the 2024 work plan, and map the local housing ecosystem. The committee also agreed to invite the new Housing Authority CEO to present at a future meeting and to consider bringing back the "Build" and "Connect" task forces to help formulate recommendations.
Impact
These decisions and discussions aim to refine how the city allocates housing funds and addresses housing supply. By advancing the HTF recommendations, the committee is moving toward a policy that explicitly protects against source-of-income discrimination and adjusts scoring to prioritize the depth and quantity of affordable units. The inclusion of energy efficiency in the scoring criteria, prompted by public input, reflects a focus on long-term cost savings and quality of life for residents. The upcoming Missing Middle Housing Study and the December retreat will further shape the city’s approach to housing density and long-term planning.
Meeting Video & Transcript