Affordable Housing Advisory Committee – October 5, 2023
October 5, 2023 at 9:34 AM
- 1 h 53 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: October 5, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) met on October 5, 2023, to review the city’s new Affordable Housing Plan, discuss revisions to the Housing Trust Fund (HTF) policy, and address zoning concerns related to displacement. The meeting included presentations from external partners, staff updates on ongoing projects, and public comment on key housing initiatives.
Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the September meeting, with a correction noted regarding who called the meeting to order. Regarding the Housing Trust Fund policy recommendations, the committee voted to carry a motion tasking the drafting work group to revise the proposed scorecard. Specifically, the work group was directed to create separate scoring tracks for ownership and rental projects and to explore criteria for using HTF funds as a grant. This decision means the HTF document will not be finalized at this meeting; instead, the work group will revise the recommendations and bring them back for a vote at the next meeting in November. The meeting was adjourned by motion.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the development of the city’s new Affordable Housing Plan, presented by Jarrah Smith, Program Director for Equitable Housing Solutions at Enterprise Community Partners. Smith outlined a process currently in the "research and discovery" phase for 2023, moving to strategy development in 2024. Key milestones include a resident engagement roundtable, a housing needs assessment, and a racial equity impact assessment. Smith emphasized the goal of creating a "national model," stating, "I'm encouraging my team, I'm encouraging the city of Asheville to be bold, be innovative, and be a leader in this space." Committee members debated the scope of the plan, including income levels and the integration of existing local studies such as the Missing Middle Housing Study and the Reparations Commission housing team.
The committee also engaged in a detailed debate on the HTF policy, specifically regarding the inclusion of a grant option. While the current fund is a revolving loan, some members argued that grants are necessary for the economics of permanently affordable projects to work. One committee member noted, "I think where we do need to use grants are when we get to these projects that are 100% affordable... If there is no limit to your affordability period, then I think it's perfectly safe to say it can be in the range [of a grant]." Another member expressed concern that if the policy is not grounded in the reality of applicants, it may not be effective. Additionally, the committee discussed the intersection of zoning and affordability, noting that the upcoming change to the Cottage UDO (flag lot zoning) is set to go before City Council on October 24. Members discussed the need to engage with stakeholders to address the "density vs. affordability" question, potentially during the committee’s scheduled retreat on December 7, which the Chair clarified is a work session rather than a spa treatment.
Community Input Public commenters addressed the committee on the Affordable Housing Plan, the HTF policy, and zoning. A community health worker and lifelong housing recipient shared their perspective on the lived experience of affordable housing, emphasizing the stress of recertifications and racial disparities; the Chair thanked the commenter, noting their input would be valuable for the resident engagement roundtable. Another resident expressed general support for the plan. Regarding the HTF policy, a representative for Disability Partners asked for language guaranteeing that the project plan submitted for scoring is the same one presented to City Council to prevent changes after community support is gathered. The Chair thanked the commenter but did not explicitly state if the committee would adopt this specific language change at this time, as the motion on the floor focused on scoring tracks and grants. A Government Relations and Grants Manager for Asheville Habitat expressed strong support for policies preventing source of income discrimination, noting that one in three housing vouchers in Buncombe County goes unused. A resident and voucher recipient, as well as a Housing and Wages Organizer for Just Economics, also voiced support for policies combating income discrimination and enhancing rental assistance acceptance. The Chair thanked each of these commenters. Finally, a public commenter requested that the committee consider a "streamlined affordable rebate program" to accompany the Cottage UDO zoning change to encourage individual homeowners and landowners to participate in affordable housing solutions. In response, a committee member directed staff to review the HTF revisions to ensure they do not prevent affordable development resulting from the upcoming ordinance changes, stating, "Let's just anticipate, let's future proof this policy to the extent that we can with things that we know are likely to happen."
Follow-ups The Enterprise team committed to looking into tracking affordability periods, preserving naturally occurring affordable housing, and assessing housing conditions. They also agreed to connect with the Reparations Commission housing team and the Missing Middle Study team to avoid duplicating work. Staff agreed to look into the timing of the November Housing and Community Development (HCD) meeting to ensure HTF recommendations can be processed in time for the December RFP release and to coordinate with the county on application windows. Staff also agreed to discuss the possibility of having the Missing Middle Study consultants present to the AHAC committee, potentially at the December retreat. Additionally, staff was asked to review the Housing Trust Fund revisions to ensure they do not prevent affordable development resulting from the upcoming ordinance changes.
Impact These discussions and decisions are significant for residents as they shape the future of affordable housing in Asheville. The move to separate scoring tracks for rental and ownership projects in the HTF aims to address potential disadvantages for small-scale homeownership projects, while the exploration of grant options seeks to make permanently affordable projects economically viable. The integration of racial equity into the new Affordable Housing Plan and the focus on engaging those directly impacted by the housing crisis aim to ensure that city policies better reflect the needs of the community. Furthermore, the committee’s attention to zoning changes and the potential for displacement highlights an effort to balance development incentives with the preservation of affordable housing options for long-term residents.
Meeting Video & Transcript