Reparations Commission – October 16, 2023
October 16, 2023 at 5:56 PM
- 2 h 5 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On October 16, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Community Reparations Commission convened to address significant operational changes, review the status of data collection, and debate the future timeline of its work. The meeting focused on the resignation of the Project Manager, the introduction of a framework for a permanent accountability agency, and a resolution to extend the commission’s term.
Key Decisions
The commission took several formal votes during the session. First, the minutes from the September 18 meeting were approved by voice vote. Second, a motion to move the discussion of the Project Manager’s resignation to the top of the agenda passed with a vote of 9-8. The most significant decision of the evening was the extension of the commission’s term. An amendment to change the extension timeframe from "two years" to "December 2025" passed 13-3. Subsequently, the amended resolution to extend the term to December 2025 was passed 10-4, with one member unable to vote. The meeting was adjourned by voice vote.
Discussion Highlights
The meeting opened with the announcement that Ms. Edwards, the Project Manager, would transition to the role of Administrative Support Manager. Ms. Edwards stated that her involvement was not having the intended impact on the forward movement of the work, adding, "I believe in reparations for African Americans, period." In response, Salam Anaya of the City of Asheville assured the commission that the recommendations would not pause and that the existing structure would continue to develop them.
Staff reported that approximately 75% of data requests from the Interdisciplinary Focus Areas (IFAs) are complete. Of the remaining open requests, about one-third are labeled "impossible to deliver," primarily due to state-level restrictions on criminal justice data. Dr. Mary Slapender of the Education IFA presented a framework for a permanent reparations accountability agency, which would oversee the implementation of all IFA recommendations and include an oversight committee and a community accountability board. Dr. Slapender noted, "The Commission is at a pivotal moment where we cannot lose that momentum but rather focus on the reward."
The commission also debated the timeline for its work. DK Woods, the County Mayor, indicated that the April timeline is not a hard stop but emphasized that a "pretty detailed, significant justification" would be required to support a two-year extension. Brenda Mills of the City of Asheville similarly stated that the commission would need to provide detail about how the work would look different to justify an extension beyond three to six months. One commissioner expressed frustration regarding the arbitrary nature of the timeline, stating, "I don't care about respect. I care about my people." Another commissioner suggested exploring global accountability mechanisms rooted in legacy Black neighborhoods.
Community Input
During public comment, a resident criticized the lack of standard operating procedures for inviting community members to join the commission, describing the process as "highly exclusive" and noting that many younger community members are interested in serving. A commissioner responded by expressing frustration regarding generational differences in productivity before leaving the meeting.
Follow-Ups
Staff agreed to document and provide the specific reasons and sources for any data requests that are denied or cannot be fulfilled. City and County staff are meeting the following week to map out the transition of duties from the departing Project Manager; Vernisha Crawford will facilitate meetings moving forward, and additional staff are being added on the city side. The draft community engagement proposal will be placed on the November agenda for further discussion and refinement. Finally, the commission must provide detailed justification to the City Council and County Commission to support the approved extension of the term to December 2025.
Impact
This meeting marked a pivotal shift in the commission’s operations, as it formally extended its term to December 2025, allowing for continued work on reparations recommendations. The transition of the Project Manager role and the introduction of a draft community engagement plan indicate a restructuring of how the commission will manage outreach and staffing. The requirement to provide detailed justification to the City Council and County Commission for the timeline extension means that the commission must now clearly define how its work will differ in the extended period to maintain support from local government bodies.
Meeting Video & Transcript