Equity & Engagement Committee – October 13, 2023
October 13, 2023 at 2:01 PM
- 37 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On October 13, 2023, the City of Asheville Equity and Engagement Committee held a specially called remote meeting to address the allocation of remaining funds from the Strategic Partnership Grant Program. The primary focus of the session was determining how to distribute $50,000 in unspent funds from the first round of grants. Due to technical difficulties with the public input platform, live call-in comments were not possible, and residents were directed to submit comments via email.
Key Decisions
The committee took three formal actions during the meeting. First, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. Second, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to allocate the $50,000 to Asheville Peak Academy. This decision deviated from both the staff recommendation to roll the funds over to the next cycle and the evaluation panel’s recommendation to fund the YWCA’s "Light a Path" program. The committee cited Peak Academy’s recent improvements in math and reading proficiency data as the primary reason for this choice. Third, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to direct staff to identify additional funding sources for the Strategic Partnership Grant Program to address anticipated greater need with reduced funds.
Discussion Highlights
Staff presented an update on the grant program, noting that 31 applications were received in Round 1 (Summer 2022) with 9 awards, and 23 applications in Round 2 (Spring 2023) with 6 awards. Staff explained that Round 2 funds have not yet been distributed because contracts are not fully executed, a process that can take 3–4 months due to the time required for agencies to provide signatures, insurance certificates, and other paperwork. Rachel Taylor, Economic Development Division Manager, noted that timing varies depending on how quickly agencies can provide required materials like certificates of insurance.
The committee debated whether the scoring rubric should be treated as a strict guarantee of funding or as a guide. Some members argued that relying too heavily on scores can favor organizations that tell good stories over those doing "heavy lifting" in the community. Chair Shaneeca Smith stated, "I’m leaning into allocating the $50,000 to an organization... I have been looking at some ELG data results from a few organizations and I see that Peak Academy has some outstanding improvement in growth areas in math proficiency and in reading... my recommendation is to recommend the approval of the allocation of $50,000 in strategic partnership grant funding for Peak Academy." Councilwoman Sage Turner initially expressed a preference for rolling the funds over, stating, "I would rather keep it clean and say we had this money that wasn't utilized. We're going to roll it over... I'm on board with one thing [Option 1]." However, she later voted in favor of the motion to fund Peak Academy. Councilwoman Kim Roney noted that stepping out of scoring rubrics can "weaken our processes and the trust around our processes," but she also voted in favor of the motion to fund Peak Academy and the motion to seek additional funding.
Follow-ups
Staff agreed to make materials available for public inspection in future committee postings, specifically addressing the formatting of evaluation scores, after a council member noted that Round 2 evaluation scores were not available in the same format as Round 1. Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, stated, "We appreciate the feedback that you've given on the desire for the formatting that you want the materials in. And we will definitely make any materials that the committee wants to make available for public inspection available with future council committee material posting." Additionally, staff committed to working with the Finance Department to identify efficiencies to streamline the contract execution process for future grant cycles. The committee also directed staff to look for additional funding options for the Strategic Partnership Grant Program.
Impact
This meeting determined the recipient of $50,000 in grant funding, selecting Asheville Peak Academy based on academic improvement data rather than the highest scoring applicant or a rollover to future cycles. The decision highlights a shift in how the committee applies its scoring rubric, prioritizing demonstrated impact in specific areas like math and reading proficiency. Furthermore, the commitment to streamline contract execution and improve the public availability of evaluation materials aims to address delays in fund distribution and enhance transparency in the grant-making process.
Meeting Video & Transcript