Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment – September 20, 2023
September 20, 2023 at 3:30 PM
- 1 h 59 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville’s Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment held a virtual meeting on September 20, 2023. The agenda included updates from various working groups, a strategic plan for renewable energy, a proposed bike lane project, and a detailed staff presentation on single-use plastics. The meeting concluded with public comments and a discussion of upcoming committee activities.
Key Decisions
The only formal vote taken during the meeting was the approval of the May meeting minutes. A motion to approve the minutes was made by Joel Osgood and seconded by Sophie Mullinax. The vote was taken via roll call and passed unanimously, with all present members voting in favor. No other motions or formal decisions were recorded, and the meeting was adjourned after the public comment period.
Discussion Highlights
Staff member Bridget Herring presented a comprehensive analysis regarding a potential policy to ban single-use plastic bags and styrofoam. Key findings indicated that there is no clear statutory authority for a mandatory fee, making Asheville the first in North Carolina to attempt this. Herring noted that a new state budget provision, revealed the day before the meeting, may explicitly prohibit local action on this issue. She stated that the team would need to "hold tight" and see how the state budget provision shakes out before finalizing recommendations. Additionally, Herring highlighted that current sanitation services are inadequate to capture lightweight plastic litter, which contaminates recycling and ends up in rivers. Targeted outreach to underrepresented communities showed lower support levels for the ban compared to the general population, with concerns regarding cost and access.
Vice Chair Steven Baron provided updates from the Community Resilience Working Group, noting that the group is beginning to provide feedback on the "Climate Justice" tab of the city’s Simplicity website. He also discussed the Urban Heat Mapping study led by Asheville Greenworks, where data collection via volunteer sensors was completed in July. Baron suggested exploring short-term remedies for urban heat, such as reflective paints and energy-efficient HVAC systems like mini-splits, noting that trees take 20 years to mature.
Sophie Mullinax reported that the Missing Middle Housing Working Group is nearing completion, with a final meeting expected within the next month. She emphasized that walkable, mixed-use housing is key to reducing car travel and increasing affordability. Mullinax also presented an update on the proposed protected bike lane along Patton Avenue near Pritchard Park. While the Greenway and Multimodal Transit Committees have written letters of support, City Council has not yet voted on the project. Mullinax encouraged individual members to write letters of support to Council, stating that the project aligns with the city’s 2036 transportation vision and safety goals.
Representatives from the Green Built Alliance presented the "Blue Horizons Project" strategic plan, which outlines three pathways to reach 100% renewable energy by 2042: energy efficiency, electrification, and greening the grid. The plan identifies 17 key initiatives, with top priorities being weatherization of low-income homes, electrifying heating sources, and promoting solar PV. The presenters requested the committee’s support in advocating for the plan’s adoption by City Council.
Community Input
Three public comments were received via phone, primarily regarding the single-use plastic reduction item. One public commenter, representing the Plastic Free WNC Coalition, expressed strong support for the policy, arguing it is well-vetted and necessary to address litter and microplastics. They urged the committee and Council to move forward despite the new state budget language, noting that the budget has not yet been passed. Chair Tim Ormond asked if the committee could respond to the comment. Staff member Bridget Herring clarified that public comments are for receiving information and that the committee had already discussed the item earlier in the meeting. She noted that if any member wished to make a statement, they could do so at the end of the meeting. No member made a specific reply to the content of this comment.
A second public commenter, representing Mountain True and Plastic Free WNC, thanked staff for the outreach and asked for clarification on the number of people reached via targeted outreach. They reiterated that the state budget provision has not been voted on, so the city retains authority under the Solid Waste Management Act. They also challenged lifecycle cost studies of alternative materials, arguing they fail to account for plastic’s end-of-life impacts. Members did not respond to this specific comment.
A third public commenter stated that their group had just submitted a grant to help with marketing, outreach, and reusable bag distributions. The chair confirmed there were no more callers in the queue. No other members or staff provided specific replies to the content of the comment regarding the grant or reusable bags.
Follow-ups
Staff member Bridget Herring stated that staff will utilize the summary of findings to develop policy options for City Council and will present them at the Environment and Safety Council Committee meeting. She also stated that the team will wait to see how the state budget provision shakes out before finalizing recommendations.
Regarding the 100% Renewable Energy Plan, Chair Tim Ormond stated the committee would "stay in your corner to support however we can" and asked the presenters from the Green Built Alliance to keep the committee posted on developments.
For the bike lane project, Sophie Mullinax offered to send talking points to members who wish to write individual letters of support to City Council. Staff clarified that members may identify themselves as SAC members in their letters but should not state they are representing the committee. Vice Chair Steven Baron noted that the committee should not take a collective vote or letter on this issue due to procedural timing and potential conflicts of interest, but individual action is permitted.
Staff also stated that the Resilience Working Group’s feedback on the Simplicity platform and climate justice map is expected to be incorporated over the fall and early winter, with availability hoped for in the new year.
Impact
This meeting addressed critical environmental and infrastructure issues affecting Asheville residents. The discussion on single-use plastics highlighted the tension between local environmental goals and potential state-level restrictions, with staff indicating that policy options for City Council will depend on the final state budget. The urban heat mapping study and the push for short-term cooling remedies aim to provide immediate relief to residents in vulnerable areas before long-term solutions like tree planting can mature. The strategic plan for 100% renewable energy by 2042 offers a roadmap for reducing carbon emissions and increasing energy resilience, while the proposed bike lane project seeks to improve road safety and reduce car dependency. These discussions provide a foundation for future City Council decisions on environmental policy, transportation, and climate resilience.
Meeting Video & Transcript