Skip to main content

Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment – May 17, 2023

May 17, 2023 at 3:30 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Mar 15 meetingNext: Sep 20 meeting
  • 2 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville’s Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment held a virtual meeting on May 17, 2023. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates from three working groups (Energy and Carbon, Resilience, and Stormwater Green Infrastructure), a departmental update, and a detailed review of the Plastic Reduction Project.

Key Decisions

The committee’s only formal vote at this meeting was to approve the minutes from March. A motion to approve was made by Joel Osgood and seconded, passing unanimously with 7 ayes and 0 nays. No motions, votes, or final decisions were made regarding the single-use plastic ordinance or any other policy items.

Discussion Highlights

Missing Middle Housing and Zoning The Energy and Carbon Working Group provided an update on the Missing Middle Housing Advisory Committee, which is studying zoning, tree canopy, and demographics. Sophie Mullinax described missing middle housing as a potential solution to the affordable housing crisis, noting it is designed to blend into existing neighborhoods. She also raised concerns that such development could impact tree canopy more than single-family development. Steve Baron noted that two-thirds of the city’s neighborhoods currently only allow single-family homes and asked if the study would consider relaxing these zoning restrictions. Councilwoman Ullman, serving as the City Council Liaison, stated that the city hopes to align the timeline of this study with an urban forestry master plan to manage growth more strategically.

Resilience and Emergency Planning The Resilience Working Group updated the committee on the Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) and Continuity of Operations Plan (COOP). Bridget Herring, the Sustainability Director, requested that community members and committee members participate in the associated surveys. Michael Totten asked if railroad cargo posing hazardous conditions is considered in these plans; Ashley Case, who presented the update, noted this was not specifically included in the survey but suggested it was a good point to raise.

Plastic Reduction Project Staff presented findings on the city’s ability to manage single-use plastic waste. Jess Foster from Sanitation stated that current municipal services are inadequate to capture and manage these wastes, and that changing services to do so is not feasible. Bridget Herring presented results from a public engagement survey, highlighting high resident support but low business participation. Councilwoman Ullman called the citizen support a "slam dunk," noting that approximately 7% of the population responded in favor. Steve Baron countered by questioning how representative that 7% is, specifically regarding those who rely on single-use plastic bags.

Follow-ups

Several members and staff members explicitly agreed to take further actions:

  • Sophie Mullinax stated she would share updates from the Missing Middle Housing Advisory Committee with the Sustainability Advisory Committee "as often as possible" and plans to raise the issue of all-electric buildings and solar-capable roof lines at those meetings.
  • Michael Totten offered to provide information on all-electric buildings if the advisory group needs it.
  • Jess Foster agreed to determine the capacity of the private recycler Trex to process additional clean plastic bags.
  • Bridget Herring stated that staff will continue gathering input from residents and businesses, including developing strategies to engage "missing voices" such as grocers and restaurants, and that the team has requested quotes for "ground teams" to help host events.

Impact

This meeting marked a significant step in the city’s sustainability efforts, particularly regarding the Plastic Reduction Project. While the committee did not vote on a new ordinance, the presentation of data showing that current sanitation infrastructure cannot handle single-use plastics, combined with strong public survey results, provides the context for future recommendations to the City Council. Additionally, the alignment of the missing middle housing study with urban forestry planning aims to help the city balance the need for affordable housing with the preservation of tree canopy.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches