Historic Resources Commission – September 13, 2023
September 13, 2023 at 4:03 PM
- 6 h 34 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: September 13, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission convened on September 13, 2023, to review a comprehensive agenda of five primary items, including a major hotel development, infrastructure repairs, and National Register nominations. The meeting began with the unanimous adoption of the minutes from the previous August meeting. The Commission then proceeded to deliberate on Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) applications and preservation nominations, engaging in detailed discussions regarding design guidelines, historic district standards, and procedural timelines.
The most significant decision of the evening concerned the Biltmore Village Hotel Development (Buildings 1–4) within the Biltmore Village historic district. Staff raised concerns that facade heights exceeded the 30-foot benchmark and that the massing of Building 4 impacted views of the Cathedral. In response, the applicant’s architect presented revised plans, including a three-foot aggregate height reduction, a redesign of Building 2 to a mercantile style, and stepped-down corners for Building 4. The Commission debated the balance between historic and contemporary styles before voting to approve the COA. A subsequent motion to issue the COA with the condition that revised elevations of Building 4 be submitted for staff review and approval also passed.
The Commission also addressed an after-the-fact application for 246 Cumberland Avenue in the Montford Historic District, which sought to replace a previously approved metal fence and pool decking with a new brick wall and brick paving. The applicant’s attorney objected to the inclusion of a State Historic Preservation Office letter and submitted an architect’s affidavit, arguing that the 180-day review period had expired. The Commission voted not to accept the affidavit as expert testimony. Following a debate on whether the wall met Montford design standards regarding historic precedent, height, and material, the Commission voted to approve the COA for the pool decking only and to deny the COA for the brick wall.
Infrastructure improvements were addressed through a project to replace approximately 1,970 linear feet of undersized, century-old vitrified clay sewer pipes along Cherokee Road in the Albemarle Park Historic District. Discussion focused on construction methods, impacts on historic trees, and the appropriate materials for road resurfacing. The Commission unanimously approved the COA with conditions regarding tree removal/replacement and surface restoration. Additionally, a motion to issue the COA with the condition that if more than 50% of existing asphalt curbing is damaged, it must be replaced with stone curbing, passed unanimously.
Several other applications were resolved during the meeting. For 211 Montford Avenue, the Commission unanimously approved and issued a COA for new steel garage doors, noting the accessory structure is non-contributing and likely post-World War II construction, making steel a compatible material. For the Montford Historic District Carriage House & Pool Deck resubmittal, the Commission voted to approve the COA, with two members voting "No" regarding skylights, and subsequently issued the COA unanimously. The Commission also unanimously recommended approval of the Walton Street Park and Pool National Register nomination to the State Historic Preservation Office, which updates information regarding the ballpark and basketball courts as "not contributing" elements. The Woolworth Building application was reviewed preliminarily, with no vote taken.
The 101 Santee Street retaining wall application was continued to the October meeting for further review of mitigation options, such as grouting joints, staining, or adding veneer, to ensure compatibility with Montford standards. Regarding the Biltmore Village Hotel, the applicant’s team agreed to reduce the expression of Building 4’s step-down corners to 15 feet and lower the cantilever by approximately one foot. Staff agreed to work with legal and permitting staff to clarify the procedural timeline, noting the October meeting is the last before the 180-day statutory decision window closes. For the Albemarle Park sewer line, staff agreed to notify the Commission if damage to asphalt curbing exceeds 50%, triggering the requirement for stone replacement, and to revisit historic road paving materials when Public Works proposes a wholesale resurfacing project. For 101 Santee Street, the architect and builder agreed to create a larger mock-up section of the wall with grouted joints and potentially adjusted staining or veneer for review at the October meeting. Finally, staff agreed to email members to schedule a joint site visit for the Woolworth Building and to check for quorum for a potential October 16 meeting date.
Meeting Video & Transcript