Skip to main content

Historic Resources Commission – August 9, 2023

August 9, 2023 at 4:03 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jul 12 meetingNext: Sep 13 meeting
  • 1 h 9 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: August 9, 2023

The Historic Resources Commission (HRC) of the City of Asheville convened on August 9, 2023, to conduct evidentiary hearings for three Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) applications. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous July session, which passed after a motion was made and seconded. The Commission then reviewed applications for trail improvements at the Thomas Wolfe Cabin site, basement access doors at a Montford Historic District home, and exterior modifications to another property in the Montford Historic District.

Key Decisions

The Commission issued a Certificate of Appropriateness for the application at 397 Azalea Road, the historic Thomas Wolfe Cabin site. The project involves improving existing single-track hiking trails and constructing new sections on the landmark property. The motion to approve the COA was made, seconded, and passed unanimously, with all members voting "Aye" and no members voting "Nay" or abstaining. The COA was issued with no conditions. Additionally, a motion to continue a separate Biltmore Village application to the September meeting was made, seconded, and passed.

For the application at 134 Flint Street, which requested the installation of basement access doors on the north elevation of a historic home, the Commission also voted unanimously to approve the COA. All members voted "Aye," with no "Nay" votes or abstentions. This approval included one condition: the rendering for the bulkhead door must be submitted for staff review and approval.

The Commission did not record a vote for the application at 185 Pearson Drive. The transcript ends during the discussion of this item, which involved rebuilding a rear porch, replacing non-original windows and doors, and adding a new deck. Consequently, no decision was finalized for this application at the August 9 meeting.

Discussion Highlights

During the review of the Thomas Wolfe Cabin trails, staff noted that while the project could have been handled administratively, it was brought to the Commission because the city had not yet begun implementing the master plan for the site. Staff also highlighted that the trails would be built to the highest sustainable standards in the industry and that the Asheville Unpaved Alliance agreed to maintain the trails for three years before the city’s parks department would take over maintenance.

Regarding 185 Pearson Drive, the Commission debated the use of horizontal lap screening for the new deck. Staff described the material as "horizontal lattice" or "foundation sheathing," noting that guidelines typically call for square lattice. A Commissioner expressed a preference for square lattice, citing the guidelines' emphasis on compatibility and compatible materials, and stated a reluctance to approve horizontal siding without a specific fact to justify it. The applicant for the property stated they were "prepared to abide by the judgment of the commission" regarding the screening material. The applicant also clarified that the primary purpose of the screening was to hide storage items from neighbors.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to contact the Director of the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County to determine the total amount of money the organization has spent on the Thomas Wolfe Cabin over the years. Additionally, staff agreed to circle back with the Commission the following month regarding the interior condition of the Thomas Wolfe Cabin, potentially bringing the Director of Capital Management to provide an update.

Impact

These decisions affect the preservation and accessibility of historic properties in Asheville. The approval of the trail improvements at the Thomas Wolfe Cabin allows for the expansion of hiking access on a significant historic landmark, with a three-year maintenance commitment from a local alliance. The approval of basement access doors at 134 Flint Street permits modifications to a home in the Montford Historic District, subject to staff review of the door design. The ongoing discussion regarding 185 Pearson Drive highlights the Commission's role in balancing modern functional needs, such as privacy and storage, with the aesthetic standards required to maintain the character of the Montford Historic District.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches