Policy, Finance & HR Committee – September 12, 2023
September 12, 2023 at 10:00 AM
- 1 h 30 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Policy, Finance & HR Committee Recap: September 12, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee convened on September 12, 2023, to review the preliminary findings of the Water Cost of Service Study. The primary focus of the meeting was an informational presentation by the consulting firm Raftelis regarding the city’s water system finances, rate structures, and recommendations for future adjustments. The committee also approved its previous meeting minutes.
Key Decisions The only formal vote taken during the session was on the approval of the minutes, which passed with 3 ayes and 0 nays. No votes were cast on the Water Cost of Service Study or the proposed rate changes, as these items were presented for informational purposes only. Additionally, the committee did not discuss the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) or bond items; Chair Esther Manheimer stated that the meeting would conclude early, and these items would be moved to the next meeting.
Discussion Highlights Finance Director Tony McDowell provided context on the water system, noting it serves over 60,000 accounts with a $44 million budget. He highlighted that the loss of the capital improvement fee in 2021 due to a court settlement has had a "substantial impact on the overall fund budget" and the ability to fund capital improvements. Raftelis consultants Melissa Levin and Vanessa Waller explained that the study is a single-year "snapshot" focused on equity among customer classes. Levin noted that the residential class is currently "over-recovering in revenue," while commercial, irrigation, manufacturing, and wholesale classes are "under recovering."
Based on these findings, the consulting team recommended maintaining a single-tier rate structure for residential customers to minimize increases, as a tiered structure is less effective with current bimonthly billing. For commercial and manufacturing customers, the team recommended combining the two classes and narrowing the price difference between Tier 1 and Tier 2 rates to ensure equitable cost sharing. They also recommended increasing rates for the three wholesale municipal customers, who are currently under-recovering costs even after accounting for capacity fees.
Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that waiting until December to present rate options "limits us in the amount of flexibility that we have through our budget process" and creates urgency that hinders public engagement. She requested an option to freeze residential rates to avoid increases for that class. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman noted that combining commercial and manufacturing classes would likely reduce administrative complexity and that the current distinction between the two appears "arbitrary." City Manager Deborah Campbell clarified that the city does not typically make mid-year rate adjustments and that rate changes are usually tied to the budget cycle, but acknowledged the request to look at the implications of freezing residential rates.
Follow-ups Staff and Raftelis agreed to bring specific rate recommendations to City Council in December for the next fiscal year. In response to a request from Councilwoman Kim Roney, staff agreed to provide information in December on the financial impact of freezing residential rate increases while adjusting other rates to align with cost of service. Additionally, in response to a request from Councilwoman Roney and Councilwoman Maggie Ullman, staff agreed to look into whether the timeline for rate adjustments could be accelerated further to allow for more public engagement and business planning time. Water Resources Director David Melton stated that the transition to monthly billing is expected to occur in FY 2026, following the completion of the first phase of the Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) project scheduled for the end of 2025.
Impact This meeting provides residents with early insight into how the city plans to address imbalances in water rate equity. The findings indicate that residential customers are currently paying more than their equitable share of costs, while commercial, manufacturing, irrigation, and wholesale users are paying less. The upcoming December presentation to City Council will determine if these recommendations are adopted, potentially leading to rate adjustments that aim to distribute costs more fairly across all customer classes.
Meeting Video & Transcript