Skip to main content

Policy, Finance & HR Committee – June 27, 2023

June 27, 2023 at 2:01 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: May 9 meetingNext: Sep 12 meeting
  • 48 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Policy, Finance and HR Committee met on June 27, 2023, to review two primary agenda items: the 2024 Event Supports Grant and Assistance proposal and a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIGI) request for a micro-apartment project at 46 Afton Street. The committee also approved the minutes from a previous meeting.

Key Decisions

The committee unanimously voted to approve the minutes. Regarding the 2024 Event Supports Grant, the committee unanimously voted to recommend that the City Council phase out the existing Strategic Event Partnership Program due to legal concerns. The committee also voted to authorize the City Manager to enter a three-year agreement with the Asheville Area Arts Council to administer a grant fund, capped at $76,014 per year, to reimburse arts-related nonprofit events for city fees. Additionally, the committee voted to authorize a three-year agricultural development agreement with the Appalachian Sustainable Agriculture Project to continue support for the Asheville City Market.

For the 46 Afton Street LUIGI request, no formal vote was taken. After discussion, the committee agreed not to issue a recommendation, either for or against, at this level. The item will move to the full City Council for discussion and decision next month.

Discussion Highlights

Staff presented the event grant proposal, explaining that legal guidance requires government support of independent events in public spaces to be content-neutral. John Fillman, Community Event Manager, stated, "Based on legal standards, we can't continue the current program as we had it. And so that's why we're suggesting an alternate plan." When asked how the city would handle a hate group applying for a grant, Fillman noted that the grant is for "arts-based organizations" and added, "I find that to be a real long stretch that that would occur," as longstanding arts events would likely outweigh such a proposal.

Regarding the 46 Afton Street project, which includes 231 units with 47 affordable units, staff recommended delaying consideration because the current LUIGI policy does not specifically address micro-units (200–350 sq. ft.). Sasha Ryzinski, Affordable Housing Officer, explained, "The role of the land use incentive grant, however, is to subsidize the affordable units, not necessarily make the project happen per se... If there's a delay in consideration, that gives us more time to revise the policy in a more holistic way."

David Moritz, a representative for the developer, addressed questions about renewable energy, stating, "We're not far enough in the detailed design yet... but something we will consider." He emphasized that building 231 units on less than half an acre downtown is "one of the most sustainable type of apartments you can build in Asheville."

Council members debated the implications of changing policy mid-stream. One member expressed concern, stating, "The fact that we've already approved one of these in the past... I guess it just feels like if we're wanting to make a change to the Luigi, great, let's do a step back. But the fact that this is already in play... how are we going to get the development community to align to our housing goals if we change the rules midstream?" Another member supported the pause, stating, "I support the HCD recommendation to pause, including this project, while we look at the outcomes that we're trying to get at."

Follow-ups

The committee will return to the Planning and Economic Development Committee in July regarding the event grant, pending the outcome of the full Council vote. The 46 Afton Street LUIGI request is scheduled for the full City Council agenda next month. Staff are preparing to embark on an affordable housing plan in the coming months, which will include input from national experts on micro-housing development.

Impact

This meeting addresses how the city supports local events and develops housing. The shift from the Strategic Event Partnership Program to an arts-focused grant fund aims to ensure legal compliance while continuing to support cultural events and the City Market. The decision to delay the 46 Afton Street tax abatement allows the city time to revise its housing incentive policies to better address the specific needs and market dynamics of micro-apartment developments, ensuring that future incentives align with broader affordable housing goals.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches