Urban Forestry Commission – September 5, 2023 – Pt. 2 of 2
September 5, 2023 at 2:05 PM
- 45 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: September 5, 2023 (Part 2)
The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on September 5, 2023, for the second part of its meeting. The session focused on reviewing ongoing working group updates, discussing a proposed public restroom project, and examining developer-proposed code changes. No formal votes or motions were recorded during this segment of the meeting, and the chair declared the meeting adjourned with no objections.
A significant portion of the discussion centered on a proposed public restroom facility and the potential removal of mature trees on the site. Commission members expressed concern regarding the necessity of tree removal. Ed, a commission member, stated, "I’m not convinced those trees need to be removed... I would think that a public restroom under the shade of mature trees is probably much more preferable than one out in the full sun." Cecil, another commission member, voiced frustration with the project, noting, "I’m baffled... you can walk about two blocks and there’s a public toilet already." Chardin Detrich provided technical context, explaining that while the trees appear healthy, they have "a lot of stem girdling roots at the base... that’s a result of a combination of being planted too deep and or being over mulched." He warned that even if the trees are saved, the roots "are going to have to be cut or they’re going to result in tree decline and tree death."
The commission also received updates from various working groups. Regarding the Urban Forest Master Plan, Zoe Hoyle noted that the Knoxville plan’s community workshops were "very impressive" and that the team met with representatives from Urban Canopy Works and Trees Knoxville to guide their own process. In the Enforcement Working Group, staff member Keith highlighted that enforcement issues on steep slopes often arise because home buyers "had to have no idea about the, you know, what they can and cannot do on their property" due to a lack of information from realtors. Staff member Videla suggested that the city could refine its steep slope GIS layer and "put it out on an app so that everybody can access it and know more easily whether they’re in one of those zones."
The meeting also addressed legislative updates regarding two developer-proposed code changes: Flag Lots and Cottage Clusters. Sharon, a commission member, explained that in the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting, "there wasn’t 1 department that agreed with the flag lots as it was laid out," and that the Building and Addressing departments warned it would be a "major nightmare" for their systems. Patrick Gilbert summarized the current status, noting that while the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval of both proposals, the Technical Review Committee gave a "preliminary recommendation to reject both," with the Planning and Urban Design committee requesting a continuance to work out an alternative.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Patrick Gilbert agreed to reach out to the city to identify the specific department responsible for the public restroom project and to gather information to pass on to the commission by the October meeting. He also stated he may seek a legal reading from the law department regarding unsettled aspects of state subdivision law related to the Flag Lot proposal for the October meeting. Additionally, Gilbert stated he will deliver a PowerPoint presentation to the City Council’s Environment and Public Safety Committee on September 26 at 10 a.m. and will send it to the commission beforehand. Staff member Keith agreed to send an update via email regarding the staff report, as he was omitted from the agenda. Staff member Videla agreed to provide a written clarification on the relationship between Chapter 711 (building impact) and Chapter 719 (tree protection percentages) for the commission to review, and to return to the commission in October with a more detailed update on the Flag Lot and Cottage Cluster proposals.
There were no public comments from residents or members of the public during this segment of the transcript. The discussions and follow-ups outlined above will inform the commission's future work on tree preservation, enforcement strategies, and legislative proposals affecting the city's urban forest.
Meeting Video & Transcript