Urban Forestry Commission – October 3, 2023
October 3, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 2 h 46 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: October 3, 2023
The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on October 3, 2023, to review staff reports, address legislative proposals, and manage commission business. The meeting opened with a somber note, as the Commission extended heartfelt condolences to the families of Jana Aiken, wife of Urban Forester Keith Aiken, and Kate Bradford, wife of Asheville Greenworks Interim Executive Director Eric Bradford. The agenda included reviews of alternative compliance applications, updates on the Urban Forest Master Plan, and discussions on zoning amendments that could impact the city’s tree canopy.
Key Decisions and Votes The Commission took several formal actions during the meeting. A motion to amend the agenda to include a presentation on the Patton Avenue Sidewalk Project passed unanimously (5-0). The September 2023 minutes were also approved unanimously (5-0). Regarding the alternative compliance application for the Vanderbilt Apartments renovation at 75 Haywood Street, the Commission voted unanimously (5-0) to approve the request for waivers on street trees and buffer shrubs, with a recommendation to include a small hornbeam tree in the planting area instead of only shrubs. On legislative matters, the Commission voted unanimously to urge the City Council to postpone consideration of current flag lot proposals; the motion was amended to state that if the Council decides to act, it should reject the petitioner’s text amendments and instead approve the staff’s recommended text amendments. The Commission voted to not take a position on the petitioner’s text amendments regarding cottage clusters. Finally, the Commission voted unanimously to recommend the appointment of Chris DeFiore to fill the vacancy on the Urban Forestry Commission.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the proposed flag lot zoning amendments, which would allow lots with no direct street frontage. Staff analysis indicated this could open approximately 1,200 parcels for development. Chair Patrick Gilbert noted that this would likely result in more trees being removed than under existing or staff-proposed amendments. Chris Collins, Assistant Director of Planning & Urban Design, clarified that while the petitioner argued this would increase affordable housing, there is no provision in the proposed amendments requiring the resulting housing to be affordable. In contrast, staff presented amendments reducing the minimum number of units for cottage clusters from five to two in RS8 districts, clarifying that these developments would still trigger tree canopy preservation requirements.
Concerns were also raised regarding the potential sale of city-owned property at the intersection of Haywood Street and Page Avenue. Commissioner Cecil Bothwell expressed alarm that City Council members were discussing selling the property, which had previously been approved for park development with $365,000 spent on a design emphasizing tree preservation and rainwater management. Bothwell stated that selling the property would sacrifice potential urban downtown canopy. Additionally, the Commission discussed the Patton Avenue sidewalk improvement project, with Commissioner Sharon Sumrall advocating for a "less is more" approach to tree planting to ensure better soil volume and conditions.
Community Input A public commenter expressed concern that city contractors from the water and stormwater departments were staging equipment within the critical root zones of trees, causing bark damage. The commenter requested an ordinance amendment to prohibit public contractors from staging in these zones, quoting Chair Patrick Gilbert’s previous statement that "the city should be the gold standard when it comes to how our trees are treated." In response, Chair Patrick Gilbert stated the issue could be referred to a working group to determine if an ordinance change should be pursued. Mark Foster, Arborist, clarified that city employees are not "contractors" and noted he has been speaking with stormwater and water department staff to raise awareness of ordinance requirements regarding drip lines and equipment staging.
Follow-Ups Several staff and members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager, agreed to review the feasibility of a "less is more" approach to tree planting for the Patton Avenue project and to consult the Task Force on Tree Planning Standards' sliding scale recommendations before the next meeting. Ed Macy agreed to email Chris Collins bullet points regarding the boundary tree issue in Chapter 719 to assist with legal review. Nancy Watford, Zoning Plan Review Supervisor, agreed to pull two years of private property zoning enforcement cases related to trees and send them to Karen Macneil and Cecil Bothwell, while also coordinating with Todd Justice to check for additional data in other systems. The Chair will draft a letter to the City Council expressing the Commission’s views on the flag lot amendments and will email the City Clerk’s office with the recommendation to appoint Chris DeFiore. Cecil Bothwell confirmed he would bring the issue of the potential Haywood Street property sale back to the Commission at an appropriate time.
Impact These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission's active role in balancing development with tree canopy preservation. The recommendation to delay or reject the petitioner’s flag lot amendments signals a cautionary stance toward zoning changes that may increase development density without guaranteed affordability or canopy protections. The approval of the 75 Haywood Street alternative compliance, with the addition of a tree, reflects a compromise to maintain some greenery in constrained urban sites. Furthermore, the focus on the Patton Avenue project and the critical root zone staging issue underscores the ongoing effort to ensure that city infrastructure projects and maintenance practices adhere to high standards for tree health, potentially influencing future ordinance interpretations and staff training.
Meeting Video & Transcript