Skip to main content
  • 1 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Audit Committee Meeting Recap: August 24, 2023

The City of Asheville Audit Committee held a virtual meeting on August 24, 2023. The agenda focused on the status of the Fiscal Year 2023 year-end audit, the transition to a new external audit firm, and the ongoing vacancy in the internal audit position. The committee also addressed leadership changes and the schedule for upcoming meetings.

Key Decisions The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting by a vote of 4-0. With the departure of the previous chair, Council Member Sage Turner moved for Nate Hathaway to assume the role of Audit Committee Chair. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously by a 5-0 vote, officially appointing Nate Hathaway as the new chair. Regarding the format of future meetings, no formal vote was taken; Council Member Sage Turner suggested continuing with the virtual format for the remainder of the current calendar year to allow new members to adjust, with a final decision on the format for the following year to be made in November.

Discussion Highlights Finance Director Tony McDowell and Assistant Finance Director Becky Ogles presented an update on the FY2023 year-end audit, noting the transition to Cherry Becker as the new external audit firm. McDowell emphasized the significance of the final financial report, stating that it is "in many ways more important even than the budget document... because it is the document that our debt rating agencies look at to determine the financial health of the city." He also noted that the external auditors specifically asked about the internal audit vacancy and recommended that the city get the position filled to get the program running again.

A significant portion of the discussion centered on the internal audit vacancy and the organizational risk assessment. Committee Member Andrew Emory expressed concern about the timeline, stating, "I'm really concerned that we're so far down the road from when Patricia left... and it continues to just be moved down three months six months at a chunk... I'm very concerned that we're hearing yet again there's no one in this role and it's being moved down to January." In response, Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood addressed the committee, stating, "I certainly value your input and concerns. But what I want this committee to understand is that that role didn't hold us accountable. The work that we do, the processes that we have in place holds us accountable." McDowell further explained that since the internal auditor left, ethics hotline reports have been reviewed by him, Ms. Campbell, and Rachel Wood, who then provide responses to the complainants.

Follow-ups Finance Director Tony McDowell agreed to provide high-level information about ethics hotline submissions at future quarterly meetings. He also committed to providing the committee with a clear direction on the internal audit program by the January meeting, stating, "I can assure you by the time we come back to you all in January, we will have – we’ll definitely be moving in a direction with the program, whether that’s having the position filled, having it fully contracted out, and any updates that we can provide you all before then via memo or anything like that."

Next Steps The committee is scheduled to meet jointly with the Policy, Finance, and HR Committee on November 14 to review the FY23 external audit results. During that meeting, the external auditors will present their findings, and staff will present the city’s response to any identified control weaknesses.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches