Skip to main content

Audit Committee – March 16, 2023

March 16, 2023 at 3:00 PM

  • 48 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Audit Committee Recap: March 16, 2023

The City of Asheville Audit Committee met on March 16, 2023, to review the selection of a new external audit firm and update the committee on the city’s organizational risk assessment. The primary actions taken during the session involved the approval of previous minutes and the scheduling of future recommendations for City Council consideration.

Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the November meeting, with a recorded vote of 3 ayes and 0 nays. No vote was taken on the external audit contract. Staff indicated that the recommendation to contract with Cherry Bekaert will be presented to the City Council at their next meeting on March 28. The meeting was subsequently adjourned without objection.

Discussion Highlights Staff presented a report on the selection of Cherry Bekaert as the city’s new external audit firm, replacing PB Mayors after a five-year rotation. The presentation covered the Request for Proposals (RFP) process, scoring results, and cost comparisons. Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, noted that the cost is "about $20,000 more than last year," attributing the increase to audit firms moving away from drafting financial statements and a general market trend of fewer firms willing to work with local governments.

The committee also reviewed the results of an organizational risk assessment conducted by Cherry Bekaert. The presentation detailed the methodology, key risk factors such as grant management, infrastructure, and security, and the ranking of city departments by inherent risk. Tony McDowell clarified, "This really isn't a report on how well we're doing per se. It's really more of a report on just the inherent riskiness of these operations." He noted that Cherry Bekaert is handing off the results to the city to avoid conflicts of interest, as they are also being selected as the external auditor. Christine, a representative from Cherry Bekaert, thanked city staff, stating, "We are not a gotcha auditor firm. And we were really here to add value... everyone was open, honest, receptive."

Discussion also touched upon the internal audit function. Debbie Evenchik emphasized the importance of internal audit for future funding, stating, "If you're going to be looking at some kind of public funding for capital improvements, it's going to be important that we get a clean opinion in relation to our controls... I think internal audit is critical in helping the city to ensure that the city... checks and balances are in place." Sage Turner raised concerns about budget constraints, noting, "I don't normally hear those small little budget items until they're baked and get to us. But is that something that needs to be addressed?" Deborah Campbell, the City Manager, addressed the difficulty in hiring an internal auditor, stating, "I just want to express that we definitely understand the critical nature of this position. And I don't want anyone to think that we're overlooking and that this isn't a sense of urgency for us. It is."

Follow-ups Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, agreed to bring back more detailed information regarding the specific observations and recommendations from the risk assessment at the committee’s next meeting. He also stated that Human Resources is working on a revamped internal auditor position description and hopes to put the job announcement back out in the next month or so. Additionally, he stated that the intent is to find a way to fund contracted internal audit work as part of the budget to be presented in May. Sage Turner stated, "I'll be sure to follow up in our budget sessions about this concern," referring to the budget constraints for the internal audit function.

Impact These discussions highlight the city’s efforts to maintain financial transparency and robust internal controls. The transition to a new external auditor and the ongoing focus on internal audit capabilities are significant for residents, as these functions ensure that city funds are managed responsibly and that the city remains eligible for various forms of public funding for capital improvements.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches