Design Review Committee – August 17, 2023
August 17, 2023 at 12:25 PM
- 1 h 22 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Design Review Committee of the City of Asheville convened on August 17, 2023. The meeting was conducted as an informal review rather than a formal session because the committee did not have a quorum, with only four of the nine members present. Consequently, no official votes were taken on any agenda items, including the approval of minutes or the design review of the primary project on the docket.
Key Discussions and Decisions The primary agenda item was an informal review of the Tempo Hotel project located on Ann and Carter Streets. Staff presented an overview of the site and major design changes made since the last review, which included a revised Carter Street frontage with a pulled-back entrance, updated streetscape treatments, and a separate leasable space on the Anne Street side. The presentation also covered updated landscaping, such as a "boulder garden," and architectural details like a "butterfly" roof articulation.
During the discussion, committee members raised several concerns regarding the design’s urban integration. One member noted that on Carter Street, none of the buildings meet the front property line and that 50% of the frontage is dedicated to cars, stating, "It doesn't feel like an urban building to me." Another member expressed dissatisfaction with the dominance of the vehicular entrance, comparing it unfavorably to the Cambria Hotel and wishing for a more urban feel. In response, the applicant’s team, represented by Whitney Van Howie and Tony Houser, indicated they were pleased with the relief provided to Carter Street by pulling the entrance back. Staff member Tony Houser suggested that reducing the driveway width by two or four feet to 20 feet would still accommodate vehicle turning but would slow traffic, a change the team agreed to look into.
Because no formal vote could be taken due to the lack of quorum, the committee did not approve or reject the design. Instead, the four members present informally agreed to attempt to schedule a special meeting for August 31st to conduct a formal review before the next regular meeting. Chair Christina Roush stated, "In light of not having a quorum today, we can't officially vote on anything... but we can still have an informal staff presentation and discussion with the applicant that'll hopefully be beneficial, and we'll just continue the item until September." She further noted, "Let's shoot for the 31st, that's in two weeks. If we can, if we can... I think with the online option, I can confirm that as well... So I'll keep you all posted."
Other Topics The committee also discussed the formation of an advisory committee for the I-26 connector project, specifically regarding the Patton Avenue downtown corridor study. Members noted that while the Design Review Committee does not have an official remit over infrastructure projects, they want to ensure design input is included in the advisory group. Additionally, staff mentioned that the Downtown Commission is beginning to pull the Design Review Committee into conversations regarding new design guidelines, which will be discussed further in the coming months.
Follow-ups Chair Christina Roush agreed to investigate the logistics of holding a special meeting on August 31st, including whether it could be held virtually, and to notify members and the applicant. The applicant’s team agreed to review and address specific design concerns raised by the committee, including revisiting the height and continuity of the perimeter wall on Anne Street, addressing the junction where roof lines meet on the northeast corner, integrating a tree from the architectural plan into the landscape plan, considering reducing the driveway width to slow vehicle traffic, exploring options for screening rooftop mechanicals, and revisiting paving materials to create a more continuous pedestrian experience. Staff member Clay noted that he would ensure the applicant’s team is aware of the changes and that the committee will continue to monitor the project for the formal review.
Impact This meeting serves as a preliminary step in the design review process for the Tempo Hotel. Because the formal review was deferred to a potential special meeting on August 31st, no final decision on the project’s design has been made. The informal discussion allowed the committee and the applicant to identify specific areas for improvement, such as traffic calming measures and urban design integration, which the applicant has agreed to address prior to the next review.
Meeting Video & Transcript