Design Review Committee – September 21, 2023
September 21, 2023 at 12:30 PM
- 1 h 10 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: September 21, 2023
The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a hybrid meeting on September 21, 2023, to review proposed development projects and approve previous meeting records. The committee’s primary actions involved approving the minutes from the July 20 and August 17, 2023, meetings, continuing the review of a project at 22 Carter Street, and recommending approval for a public space project at 27 and 22 Church Street. Additionally, the committee conducted an informal review of a proposed hotel at 215 Haywood Street.
Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the July 20 and August 17, 2023, meetings as written. For the project at 22 Carter Street, the committee voted unanimously to continue the formal design review to the October 19, 2023, meeting. Regarding the proposal to convert a parking lot at 22 Church Street into a pocket park and plaza and to modify the courtyard at 27 Church Street, the committee voted to recommend approval subject to three specific conditions. The vote was not unanimous, with all members voting in favor except one who voted opposed. The conditions require the applicant to review the height of the proposed fencing on both the north and south sides of Church Street, the materials for the wall facing the south side of the street, and the detailing of the sliding gates and paved apron meeting the street.
Discussion Highlights The most significant debate centered on the 27 and 22 Church Street project, specifically the aesthetic and functional aspects of the new fencing and walls. One member expressed concern that the proposed fence was "too tall" and "very intimidating," stating that it felt as though it was "clearly telling everyone this fence is here to keep people out." Another member advocated for consistency in materials, noting that the surrounding area uses brick and suggesting that the new wall should "tie it all in" with the existing brick language rather than introducing a different material.
The committee also conducted an informal review of the proposed six-story Courtyard by Marriott hotel at 215 Haywood Street, which includes 115 guest rooms, a rooftop restaurant, and structured parking. Discussion focused on the building’s massing, exterior materials, and the prominence of the entrance. One member criticized the current entrance design, stating, "It seems like you're not sure where you want the front door to be... I would like to see you play up that corner entrance... But then when you get there, you're like, hmm, where's the front door?" Another member raised questions about transportation, suggesting a potential group shuttle service to the airport for hotel guests, while another member noted that large hotels are already required to provide shuttle services, though the frequency requirements are vague.
Community Input A public commenter addressed the committee regarding the 27 and 22 Church Street project. The commenter agreed with the committee’s concerns about the fence height, noting that other fences on the street are approximately six feet tall. However, they offered a counter-perspective, citing examples from Charleston, Florence, Italy, and Paris where high fences around cathedrals create a sense of "awesome verticality" and space for pedestrians. The commenter clarified they were not advocating for the proposed eight-foot fence but found the concept interesting. In response, a member noted that while the historical examples were interesting, the proposed fence would be made of extruded aluminum rather than forged iron, and the committee was advocating for custom gates to improve the aesthetic.
Follow-ups The landscape architect for the 27 and 22 Church Street project, Matt Fusco, stated that he would review the committee’s concerns regarding fence height, wall materials, and gate detailing. He also stated he would consider the suggestion to rotate the water feature 90 degrees to align with the "ghost" of the old church. For the 215 Haywood Street hotel project, the architect from Studio Z, Chris Sandkuler, stated that the team would likely return for another informal review to track progress on the design changes discussed, particularly regarding the building’s massing, entrance prominence, and material application.
Impact These decisions impact the streetscape and public access in downtown Asheville. The recommendation to approve the Church Street pocket park and plaza, subject to the conditions regarding fencing and materials, aims to balance the creation of a new public gathering space with the preservation of the neighborhood’s architectural character. The continuation of the 22 Carter Street review and the ongoing informal review of the Haywood Street hotel indicate that these projects are still in the design refinement phase, with the committee seeking specific improvements to ensure they integrate well with the surrounding urban environment.
Meeting Video & Transcript