Urban Forestry Commission – August 1, 2023
August 1, 2023 at 1:13 PM
- 2 h 41 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: August 1, 2023
The City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission held its regular meeting on August 1, 2023. After a brief delay due to technical difficulties with the live stream, the Commission addressed several agenda items, including the approval of previous minutes, a request for alternative compliance for a development project, and updates on ongoing city initiatives such as the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance, the New Hall Creek Sidewalk Project, and the Urban Forest Master Plan.
Key Decisions The Commission voted to approve the minutes from the July 2023 meeting (held June 27) by a vote of 5 Aye and 1 Abstain. The Commission also voted to approve an alternative compliance request for the project at 3 Regent Park Boulevard, with a recommendation to substitute seven small maturing trees for five large maturing trees; this motion passed unanimously with a vote of 7 Aye. Additionally, the Commission agreed on a new procedure for filling a current vacancy on the Commission: the Chair and Vice Chair will evaluate applications and present at least two or three top candidates to the full Commission for discussion and recommendation to the City Council.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the enforcement of the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance, specifically regarding issues at the Municipal Golf Course. Staff reported on data reporting and enforcement challenges, and the Commission discussed the need for better monitoring. Chair Patrick Gilbert recommended that the Enforcement Working Group schedule a meeting, appoint a chair, and discuss changes to enforcement on both public and private land, directing the group to liaise with the Policy Working Group and Council Liaison Kim Roney.
The Commission also reviewed a legislative proposal before the Planning and Zoning Commission that would reduce the minimum width for flag lots from 20 feet to 5 feet and reduce the minimum number of units in a cottage cluster from five to two. Staff expressed concern that these changes could undermine subdivision ordinances and allow for multiple units in RS-8 zones without proper public input, particularly while a "missing middle" housing study is ongoing. Staff confirmed that the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance applies to any major or minor subdivision, meaning the proposed reduction in cottage cluster units would still trigger tree canopy preservation requirements.
Other topics included a presentation on the New Hall Creek Sidewalk Project, which involves the removal of approximately 77 trees. Capital Projects staff noted that while placing the sidewalk on the east side of the road would result in fewer tree removals, the cost would be significantly higher. The Commission also received updates from the Policy Working Group on revisions to Chapter 719 and Chapter 20, and from the Urban Forest Master Plan Working Group. A discussion on the Missing Middle Housing Study highlighted the need for adequate public resources to track and monitor tree canopy, with staff noting that different data sources yield varying results.
Community Input Public comments were received regarding the Municipal Golf Course and the New Hall Creek Sidewalk Project. Regarding the golf course, a public commenter expressed concern that the $2,500 reimbursement from a subcontractor was insufficient to cover tree damage, noting that more than six or eight trees were affected. The commenter requested greater transparency in how violations are evaluated. In response, Commissioner Chardin Detrich stated that remediation needs to happen on more than just six trees and that the $2,500 cost is very small. Another public commenter agreed, emphasizing the community’s desire for transparency to set a precedent. A third public commenter criticized the lack of experienced personnel monitoring the site and called for immediate oversight to stop ongoing damage. City Arborist Mark Foster responded that it is too late to follow standard procedures for pruning that has already occurred and requested that staff be included in communications so urgent issues are reported directly to him.
Regarding the New Hall Creek Sidewalk Project, a public commenter questioned why the Commission was being consulted if there was no mechanism for their input to change the plan. Commissioner Chardin Detrich added that it appears decisions were made before the Commission was consulted, noting that more trees left standing would result in less stormwater. Commissioner Ed Macy questioned the process of relying on contractors to save trees without a tree survey on the site plan, stating that he does not trust contractors with trees and that the Commission must maintain transparency with the public.
Follow-ups Chair Patrick Gilbert agreed to send the City Arborist the link to public comment emails regarding the golf course so he can review the specific concerns. Sam Starbaum, a Planner, agreed to send the spreadsheet and GIS project file of the tree canopy study to the Commission members. Commissioner Ed Macy agreed to review examples of Section 7-11-3 provided by a public commenter to consider adding boundary tree language to that chapter. Zoe Hoyle stated she would try to set up a meeting within the next couple of weeks and contact the Knoxville Tree people regarding the Urban Forest Master Plan. The Chair stated that if the applicant for the zoning changes decides to pursue the proposal to City Council, the Chair will bring the issue back to the Urban Forestry Commission to determine if the Commission wishes to weigh in. The Chair and Vice Chair will review vacancy applications received by the August 24 deadline. Additionally, Asheville GreenWorks will analyze the completed heat mapping data and conduct a second site visit at the municipal golf course on August 9 regarding the nursery extension proposal.
Impact These discussions and decisions highlight the Commission’s role in balancing development with environmental preservation. The approval of the alternative compliance request allows for a specific development project to proceed with modified tree planting requirements. The focus on enforcement at the Municipal Golf Course and the review of zoning proposals underscore the ongoing tension between housing development and tree canopy preservation. The commitment to better data tracking and the review of the Urban Forest Master Plan aim to provide the Commission with the tools necessary to make informed decisions about the city’s urban forest in the future.
Meeting Video & Transcript