Urban Forestry Commission – June 27, 2023
June 27, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 2 h 6 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: June 27, 2023
The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on June 27, 2023, to address a range of urban forestry issues, including tree compliance, storm damage, and proposed ordinance changes. This meeting was held in place of the regular July 4th meeting due to the holiday. The Commission reviewed updates on the Urban Forest Master Plan, municipal golf course operations, and landscaping standards, while also voting on specific requests for alternative tree compliance and the approval of the June 2023 minutes.
Key Decisions The Commission took several formal votes during the session. A motion to add the Urban Forest Master Plan Working Group update to the agenda for presentation and discussion passed unanimously (5-0). The Commission also unanimously approved the June 2023 minutes (5-0). Most significantly, the Commission voted unanimously (5-0) to approve an alternative compliance request from the Mission Health Behavioral Health Center at 32 Apex Circle. This approval allows for the relocation of required street trees due to utility conflicts, subject to specific conditions: of the 33 required trees, 8 must be large species from a recommended list, the rest must be a mix of medium and small species, and no single species may constitute more than 20% of the total planting. Chair Patrick Gilbert clarified that this approval serves as a recommendation to the Zoning Administrator rather than a final approval.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the enforcement of steep slope ordinances. Cecil Bothwell expressed frustration regarding the lack of enforcement in these areas, stating, "It infuriates me that I've been working on this issue for 13 or 14 years now, and I can't seem to get city to enforce the law." He cited a specific instance where a neighbor clear-cut a property, causing a landslide, but was only asked to plant "some things" rather than being fined. In response to these concerns, the Commission agreed to form a new Ordinance Enforcement Working Group, with Chardin Dietrich, Karen Macneil, and Cecil Bothwell volunteering to serve.
The Commission also reviewed proposed changes to the Urban Design Ordinance (UDO) Section 711-3 regarding landscaping standards. Staff member Vidula Esafika emphasized the significance of the new soil volume standards, stating, "I believe this new soil volume standard is going to be, it is raising the bar significantly. Very, very few cities do this... the City of Asheville will be a leader in landscaping standards." Additionally, Sharon Sumrall, a Technical Review Committee Representative, raised concerns about the horticultural health of the proposed Prunus Kwanzan trees at 32 Apex Circle, noting, "If they're planted real close together, then there's not enough air circulation for them. Then they're just going to be dropping and wilting... they're really prone to fungus disease."
Follow-ups Several staff and commission members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Chris Collins, Assistant Director of Planning & Urban Design, agreed to provide the Commission with the most updated list of trees removed and pruned at the Municipal Golf Course. Vidula Esafika agreed to receive a list of questions and concerns from the Commission regarding the proposed Landscaping Standards and to share draft code language regarding light pole placement. Sam Starbaum from Planning agreed to provide the exact spacing for the proposed Prunus trees at 32 Apex Circle. Zoe Hoyle agreed to chair a special Policy Working Group meeting to discuss the intersection of missing middle housing with tree canopy and open space ordinances, with the goal of submitting recommendations to the Missing Middle Housing Advisory Committee. Finally, Chardin Dietrich, Karen Macneil, and Cecil Bothwell agreed to form the Ordinance Enforcement Working Group to review enforcement practices and report back to the Commission.
Impact These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission's focus on balancing development needs with the long-term health of the city's urban forest. The approval of the alternative compliance request at 32 Apex Circle sets a precedent for how utility conflicts are managed, ensuring species diversity and appropriate tree sizes. The formation of the Ordinance Enforcement Working Group signals a renewed effort to address gaps in enforcing existing steep slope protections, a long-standing concern for residents in those areas. Furthermore, the review of new landscaping standards suggests that future development in Asheville may face stricter requirements for soil volume and green infrastructure, potentially impacting the sustainability of new trees in urban environments.
Meeting Video & Transcript