Board of Adjustment – July 24, 2023
July 24, 2023 at 2:00 PM
- 15 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: July 24, 2023
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on July 24, 2023, to conduct its regular business. The meeting focused on the adoption of previous records and the review of a specific variance request regarding accessory dwelling units.
Key Decisions The board unanimously adopted the minutes from the May 2023 meeting. The primary decision of the evening was the approval of a variance request for the property at 167 Old County Home Road. The applicant, Tritton Braswell, sought permission to convert an existing garage into an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU). The proposed structure’s rear corner is located approximately three feet from the rear property line, which is half the six-foot setback required by the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). After a roll call vote in which all voting members cast "Aye" votes, the board approved the variance request unanimously.
Discussion Highlights During the hearing, a board member disclosed a potential conflict of interest, noting that the applicant works at the same company as the member. The chair confirmed that the applicant is not a family member, and the board proceeded with the hearing. Another board member inquired whether the existing structure fell within a sewer line easement and if this had been discussed with the Metropolitan Sewerage District (MSD). The applicant stated that his contractor confirmed with MSD that the specific easement area in question is not active, though he acknowledged the structure is technically within the easement boundary.
The board also discussed the recurring nature of such variance cases. A board member asked if there was a chance the ordinance would be changed to reduce the frequency of these hearings. Staff from Planning and Urban Design indicated that the issue may be addressed in the current "missing middle" study. The staff member suggested that deleting a specific sentence in Section 714.1 regarding non-conforming structures could allow existing structures to be converted without triggering a new variance requirement. Chair Paul Wilczynski commented on the potential impact of such a change, stating, "Let me go on record and say that if making the change results in there being monthly times when we should have a meeting but we don't have any variances, I would be sorely [missing word, likely 'missed' or 'disappointed']."
Community Input No public comments were received during the meeting. The chair noted that no members of the public were present to speak.
Follow-ups The applicant provided a letter from an adjoining neighbor stating they did not object to the project, which the board accepted for the record. Additionally, staff indicated that the issue of setback variances for existing structures is being considered as part of the ongoing "missing middle" study.
Impact This decision allows the owner at 167 Old County Home Road to proceed with converting the existing garage into an ADU, despite the structure being closer to the rear property line than the standard ordinance requires. For residents, the discussion highlights an ongoing review of the city's zoning rules. Staff noted that the "missing middle" study is currently examining whether to amend Section 714.1 to prevent existing structures from requiring variances for conversions, a change that could streamline future applications for similar projects.
Meeting Video & Transcript