Board of Adjustment – June 26, 2023
June 26, 2023 at 2:01 PM
- 3 h 34 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: June 26, 2023
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on June 26, 2023, to address three primary agenda items following the postponement of the May 2023 minutes review. The board, chaired by Paul Wilczynski, conducted evidentiary hearings for two variance requests and one appeal regarding site plan review. The meeting concluded with the denial of one variance, the approval of another, and a ruling in favor of the City on a zoning appeal.
Key Decisions and Votes
The board first voted unanimously to move the review and adoption of the May 2023 minutes to the next meeting, as the documents had only been received that morning. Regarding the variance request for an accessory structure at 173 Macon Avenue, the board voted to deny the request. The motion to approve failed with a recorded vote of two ayes (Ms. White and Chair Wilczynski) and three nays (Ms. Gutze, Mr. Fundanish, and Mr. Smith). Chair Wilczynski stated, "Unfortunately, the request for the variance is denied."
For the variance request at 5 Woodland Drive, which sought to reduce the 35-foot front setback to install an aluminum shade structure for a licensed infant/toddler play area, the board voted unanimously to approve the request. Chair Wilczynski announced, "Your request for the variance is approved." Finally, the board ruled in favor of the City on an appeal concerning two proposed townhome developments at 11 West Chapel Road and 294 Rock Hill Road. The board affirmed the staff determination that these projects constitute "different phases of a larger plan," thereby requiring Level 2 (Major Subdivision) review rather than Level 1 review. A roll call vote was taken, with recorded ayes from Ms. Godsey, Mr. Fundanish, Mr. Smith, Ms. White, and Chair Wilczynski. The Chair stated, "The ruling is in favor of the city," resulting in the denial of the appeal.
Discussion Highlights
During the hearing for the 173 Macon Avenue variance, board members expressed concern that the applicant failed to demonstrate a specific physical hardship related to the land or building orientation. One board member noted, "I just did not hear from the applicant or in the application that there was a specific hardship... to really SHOW THAT THERE WAS A PHYSICAL CONSTRAINT WITH THIS ADDITION." Staff member Chris Collins clarified that the onus is on the applicant to handle all permits associated with the project, noting that a zoning inspection could not be requested while the project was on hold. Chair Wilczynski remarked, "I feel bad when honest mistakes are made."
In the discussion for the 5 Woodland Drive variance, applicant Corey Price emphasized the urgent need for a shaded, weatherproof area for young learners, stating that creating a new licensed play space would likely render the infant room non-viable for a year. Board members debated the context of the setback, with one noting, "Those excessive front yard setbacks that I have been complaining about for a while seem to keep coming back." Another member pointed out that the property was constructed in 1965, stating, "This is the problem with all of West Asheville."
The appeal regarding the townhome developments involved significant debate over the interpretation of City Code Section 7-5-9. Witness Clay Mooney, a site planner, argued there was no connection between the two projects, stating, "They share nothing... No shared utilities. No shared walls. No shared access." He testified that combining the projects would increase costs for sidewalks and curb/gutter and hinder affordable housing goals. Witness Dr. William Chambers, owner of Kinship Homes LLC, testified that the LLCs were organized on the same date by the same accountant/attorney but are owned by different family members, and he has no interest in the APEX property. He argued, "To combine them into two, only based on the fact if they're on the same developmental timeline... you can't determine that because we don't know what the timeline is going to be."
City Planner Sam Starbaum countered that the projects are "unequivocally phases of a larger plan of development owing to a number of factors that include, but are not limited to, ownership, sanitary sewer, sidewalks, curb gutter, and landscape architect." Attorney Bob Ost, representing the appellants, argued that the ordinance is vague and that zoning cannot regulate ownership, only use. He stated, "We think that this ordinance is vague. It says 'may or may not.' We think it's vague and so vague that we think that would not survive a court challenge." City Counsel highlighted that the crux of the issue was whether the ordinance’s list of factors was exclusive. A board member commented, "We wouldn't be here if it was you, Bob, and me, Suzanne, developing two parcels. The city couldn't come to us and say, hey, Bob's doing this down next door. Y'all have to do it together." Another board member, likely Suzanne Vernon Godsey, noted, "It seems like there is no way that they wouldn't just do it all at one time." Chair Wilczynski stated, "I tend to side with the city on that particular point [regarding the non-exclusive nature of the ordinance list]."
Community Input
There were no public comments recorded for any of the agenda items. The Chair asked if there was anyone from the public who would like to speak for the Macon Avenue variance, the Woodland Drive variance, and the appeal, and in all instances, no one stepped forward.
Follow-ups
The review of the May 2023 minutes was explicitly moved to the next board meeting. Following the ruling on the appeal, the applicant must proceed with the Level 2 review process for the APEX project. No other explicit follow-ups were agreed to by staff or members.
Impact
These decisions affect specific property owners and developers in Asheville. The denial of the Macon Avenue variance means the proposed increase to the accessory structure footprint cannot proceed as requested. The approval of the Woodland Drive variance allows Evolve Early Learning to install the necessary shade structure for its infant/toddler play area. The ruling on the townhome appeal means that the APEX Family Homes project at 294 Rock Hill Road is subject to Level 2 review requirements, as the board determined it is part of a larger plan with the Kinship Homes project.
Meeting Video & Transcript