Planning and Zoning Commission – July 19, 2023 (Part 2)
July 19, 2023 at 5:57 PM
- 2 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On July 19, 2023, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened for the second part of its regular meeting. The primary agenda item was the review of a conditional zoning petition for "Project Aspire," a large-scale mixed-use development proposed for the northern section of downtown Asheville. The Commission also reviewed and approved minutes from previous meetings.
Key Decisions The Commission unanimously approved the minutes from the June 7 and June 21 meetings. During this review, a correction was noted regarding the June 7 minutes, which incorrectly referenced a July 7 meeting that did not take place. Staff confirmed that the item for 268 Carter Street, which was intended for that date, will be re-noticed for the August 2 meeting with proper mailings and sign postings.
Regarding Project Aspire, the Commission voted unanimously to continue the conditional zoning application to August 2, 2023. Chair Geoffrey Barton made the motion to continue the item to that date. No final decision on the project was made at this meeting.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented a detailed review of Project Aspire, a 10.5-acre site bounded by Woodfin/Oak, College, Charlotte, and Central Avenue that includes the current YMCA, First Baptist Church, and State Employee Credit Union Bank. The proposal includes approximately 1.1 million square feet of construction, with 400–650 residential units, a new YMCA, office and commercial space, and a hotel. Staff recommended a continuance to allow time for the Commission to review the complex details and for staff to work with the applicant on outstanding concerns regarding building massing, technical modifications, and project conditions.
Commissioners debated several key aspects of the proposal. Significant discussion centered on the proposed 1,850 parking spaces, with Commissioners questioning the necessity of such a high number given the city’s goals for walkability and public transit. The applicant clarified that the parking is intended as a public-private partnership garage, featuring a mix of reserved spaces for the hotel, YMCA, and church, alongside public spaces. Dave Crabtree, Lead Designer for the Furman Company, stated, "The parking is intended as a public parking garage... There will be reserved parking... but the design of the garage's capacities are intended to meet both reserved usage and public usage."
The Commission also discussed building massing, specifically the "40% rule" for building floor plate area above 75 feet. Dave Crabtree noted that the project currently proposes only about 22% of the allowable area above that height, utilizing a "mountain and valley" design concept to frame views and respect the historic church. He stated, "We are far below the 40 percent [floor plate area above 75 feet]... currently what's used is about a hundred thousand square foot... which is around 22 to 23 percent."
Robert Poppleton, Vice President of the Furman Company, requested a vote on the project that evening, stating, "We respectfully request that we can vote tonight... in support of approval with conditions. The spirit of collaboration we've shown along the way... we will continue that going forward." However, the Commission chose to continue the item to allow for further refinement.
Community Input A public commenter representing First Congregational United Church of Christ spoke in support of the project’s affordable housing and neighborhood benefits but raised concerns about disruption during the 2-3 year construction phase, including noise, vibration, and the loss of approximately 160 parking spaces for First Baptist Church congregants in the interim. The commenter also noted the need for their own congregation to maintain parking access for weekly programs. No specific member replied directly to this comment.
Another public commenter stated that while the project is ambitious and a good neighbor, they emphasized that Asheville is a "small mountain town" and not Greenville or Charlotte. They expressed a desire to avoid a "monstrosity" on the corner of Charlotte Street and urged the commission to ensure the final design respects the local character. No specific member replied directly to this comment.
Follow-ups Commissioners agreed to send written comments and suggested revisions to the project conditions via email to staff and the applicant to "iron out" the language before the next meeting. The applicant and developer agreed to review the commissioners' written feedback and work with staff to refine the conditions and drawings prior to the August 2 meeting. Staff will facilitate the exchange of comments between the commission and the applicant.
Impact This decision allows for further negotiation on the terms of a major downtown development before a final vote. The project includes conditions for 20% of residential units to be affordable to those earning at or below 80% of Area Median Income, preservation of healthy trees, and the use of green stormwater infrastructure. The continuance provides time to address concerns regarding building scale, parking, and streetscape improvements, such as enhanced sidewalks and off-street bike lanes, which are intended to improve the public realm in the Central Business District.
Meeting Video & Transcript