Planning and Zoning Commission – August 2, 2023
August 2, 2023 at 5:02 PM
- 3 h 30 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: August 2, 2023
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened on August 2, 2023, to review four major agenda items. The session focused on three conditional zoning requests for specific development projects and two proposed technical amendments to the Asheville Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) aimed at streamlining housing creation.
Key Decisions and Votes The Commission voted to approve all three conditional zoning requests unanimously. These approvals cover the "Project Aspire" development at 1 Oak Street, which includes a hotel, residential units, and commercial space; the West Haywood Street Apartments, a 100% affordable housing project; and the East Village Grill, which requested rezoning to allow for additional surface parking. Regarding the zoning text amendments, the Commission voted 3-1 to approve proposed changes to the flag lot and cottage development standards. Both approvals are contingent on the applicant holding a Technical Review Committee (TRC) meeting to address staff concerns before the items proceed to City Council. One commissioner voted against both text amendments, stating that the items require more work and review than a TRC meeting alone.
Discussion Highlights During the review of Project Aspire, staff recommended approval with specific project conditions. The applicant emphasized the alignment of the project with the missions of the First Baptist Church and the YMCA, while a commissioner noted the importance of integrating the project into the East End community. For the West Haywood Street Apartments, the applicant highlighted that the project is 100% affordable in perpetuity, a distinction the Chair noted as rare in their tenure. Staff for the East Village Grill expressed comfort with the approval, provided that conditions limit the use to the surface parking lot related to the front uses.
The most extensive debate occurred regarding the flag lot and cottage development amendments. Staff raised concerns that reducing the minimum width for flag lots to five feet and removing quantity limits could lead to unorganized development patterns and undermine the subdivision process. Staff also noted that reducing the cottage development minimum from five units to two would effectively permit two units in single-family districts through a "backdoor method." In response, the applicant argued that current land prices indicate a future where homes under $500,000 will be unavailable, emphasizing the need for mechanisms to finance backyard homes. The Chair urged the Commission to act on the amendments to address the housing crisis, stating, "We can't wait. We can't nibble at the edges anymore." Another commissioner supported the initiative but suggested specific refinements, such as requiring wider flag poles and limiting the number of lots per parcel to ensure fire safety.
Community Input Public comments were recorded only for the zoning text amendments. A public commenter representing a general contractor expressed full support, arguing that current systems create excessive hurdles for small builders. Another public commenter representing the Land of the Sky Association of Realtors (LOTSAR) urged immediate adoption to address the severe housing shortage, citing national data on the deficit in new home construction. A local architect and renter expressed support but suggested "tweaking" the proposals, specifically raising concerns about fire access for multiple flag lots and suggesting requirements for ribbon driveways and canopy trees. Members did not respond directly to these specific technical suggestions during the comment period, but staff and commissioners acknowledged the need to address fire access, shared driveway maintenance, and impervious surface concerns through the TRC process. No public comments were recorded for the three conditional zoning requests.
Follow-ups The applicant for Project Aspire and staff agreed to continue refining the language of specific project conditions, particularly regarding crosswalks and the role of the Design Review Committee, before the item goes to City Council. For the West Haywood Street Apartments, the Commission and applicant agreed to eliminate Condition 12 regarding impervious surface area, as the project’s coverage was close to the standard maximum. The Chair encouraged the East Village Grill applicant to ensure a pedestrian connection between the new employee parking lot and the existing restaurant entrance. For the zoning text amendments, the applicant agreed to hold a TRC meeting to address staff concerns, and staff agreed to bring their comments to that meeting. The Commission will bring the zoning text amendments back to the Planning and Zoning Commission on Wednesday, September 6, 2023, to review the outcomes of the TRC meeting and finalize the recommendation to City Council.
Impact These decisions impact the physical development of downtown Asheville and the city's housing stock. The approval of Project Aspire and the West Haywood Street Apartments moves these large-scale developments forward toward City Council review, with the latter providing permanent affordable housing. The East Village Grill approval allows for expanded parking for an existing business. The conditional approval of the flag lot and cottage development amendments signals a potential shift in how the city handles small-scale housing creation, though final adoption by City Council is pending the resolution of technical safety and planning concerns identified by staff.
Meeting Video & Transcript