Skip to main content

Historic Resources Commission – July 12, 2023

July 12, 2023 at 4:02 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jun 14 meetingNext: Aug 9 meeting
  • 2 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: July 12, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission convened on July 12, 2023, to review certificate of appropriateness requests, discuss ongoing enforcement issues, and address administrative matters. The meeting included a presentation from the Asheville Museum of History regarding its renovation and expansion plans, as well as discussions on public engagement events and commission vacancies.

Key Decisions The Commission unanimously approved the minutes from the June meeting. Regarding the request for 97 Santee Street in the Montford Historic District, the Commission unanimously approved a Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of new arched, aluminum-clad windows in the gable ends of a primary structure built in 2014. Staff noted the design was compatible with district standards for new construction. For the request at 246 Cumberland Avenue, also in the Montford Historic District, the Commission unanimously voted to continue the item to the September meeting. Additionally, the Commission unanimously passed a motion to invoke North Carolina General Statute 160D-947 to request technical advice from the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) regarding this specific application.

Discussion Highlights A representative from the Asheville Museum of History, located in the Smith McDowell House, presented an update on the museum’s transition from a historic house museum to a broader history museum for Western North Carolina. The presentation detailed renovations including a new copper roof, HVAC updates, and plaster repairs, with a planned soft opening on October 18, 2023. The initial exhibit will focus on "Palaces for the People" and fireproof building techniques.

The most significant debate centered on the 246 Cumberland Avenue request, which sought an after-the-fact Certificate of Appropriateness to replace a metal picket fence around a swimming pool with 5.5-foot brick walls. Staff noted that freestanding brick walls are rare in the Montford district, where stone and concrete are more common, and that the walls visually dominate the rear yard. Commissioner Annie McDonald, an architectural historian, questioned how the wall's location and height were consistent with design guidelines, noting that precedent walls in the district are typically located along property lines and are four feet or lower. Commissioner Will Hornaday expressed concern about the lack of landscaping, stating he would hate to see the walls torn down. Chair Sue Oliver stated, "We want to be comfortable. We want to honor your wishes and our responsibilities. So it feels to me like we need a little more time. We need more information. We need to think about it."

In other business, the Chair provided an update on an enforcement case in Billmore Village where the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) replaced historic brick curb ramps with concrete. The Chair reported that NCDOT had decided to reverse course and restore the historic standards, resolving the issue administratively without a formal notice of violation. The Chair also announced upcoming public engagement events for the PACS Square Visioning project and the Missing Middle Housing project. Finally, the Chair asked members to recommend candidates for vacancies on the Planning and Zoning Commission, specifically seeking individuals with technical knowledge in construction, architecture, design, and landscape.

Community Input A resident spoke in support of the property owners at 246 Cumberland Avenue, stating, "He's one of our community people. He's trying to help us protect you." No specific member responded directly to this comment with a quoted statement; the discussion continued with staff and other commissioners addressing the technical merits of the wall application. No public comments were recorded for the 97 Santee Street item or the other business section.

Follow-ups Staff agreed to locate and share the original 2018 findings of fact and meeting minutes regarding the initial pool approval at 246 Cumberland Avenue. Staff also agreed to check if a building permit was required for the wall construction. The Commission agreed to seek technical advice from the SHPO regarding the 246 Cumberland Avenue wall application. The applicant for 246 Cumberland Avenue agreed to provide additional evidence of traditional wall placement in Montford backyards and to consider adding more mature landscaping to the pool area before the September hearing. Staff agreed to send training materials on quasi-judicial proceedings and historic preservation standards to new commissioners. The Chair committed to sending an email to members the next day with links to the PACS Square and Missing Middle Housing project pages and a recap of the announcements. The Chair also stated they would let someone in public works know about the leftover bricks from the Billmore Village curb ramp replacement.

Impact These decisions affect the preservation standards of the Montford Historic District and the operational direction of the Asheville Museum of History. The deferral of the 246 Cumberland Avenue request ensures that the Commission can gather additional technical guidance and evidence before making a final determination on the compatibility of the proposed brick walls. The approval for 97 Santee Street allows for the completion of window installations on a newer structure within the historic district. The resolution of the Billmore Village curb ramp issue demonstrates that historic district standards apply to all entities, including state departments, and can be resolved through administrative cooperation.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches