Skip to main content

Planning & Economic Development – July 10, 2023

July 10, 2023 at 4:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jun 12 meetingNext: Aug 14 meeting
  • 43 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On July 10, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee held a remote meeting to address the deteriorating condition of the Harris Cherokee Center and to restructure the city’s support for outdoor events. The committee reviewed an annual update from the Civic Center Commission regarding critical infrastructure failures and voted on a new framework for the 2024 Special Events Program.

Key Decisions

The committee began by approving the minutes from the previous meeting. The primary actions taken involved the 2024 Special Events Program, where the committee voted to recommend three specific measures to the full City Council. First, the committee voted to phase out the city’s strategic event partnership programs for fee waivers, retaining only the 75% nonprofit discount already established in the city’s fees and charges manual. Second, the committee voted to recommend that the City Manager enter into a three-year agreement with the Asheville Area Arts Council to administer a grant fund, capped at $76,014 per year, to reimburse arts-related nonprofit events for certain fees in outdoor public spaces. Third, the committee voted to recommend a three-year agricultural development agreement with ASAP (Affiliation Sustainable Agricultural Project) for the Asheville City Market. All three motions passed with recorded votes of "Aye" from Councilwoman Sage Turner and Chair Sandra Kilgore.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Civic Center Commission’s annual update, which highlighted severe structural and mechanical issues at the Harris Cherokee Center. Donna Bailey, Chair of the Civic Center Commission, described the situation as an emergency, noting that months of ignored repair work have led to a snowballing crisis involving structural failures in the loading dock, failing HVAC systems, water leaks, and ceiling damage. Chris Port, Director of D.C.REF, detailed the critical failure of the heating and air conditioning in the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium, reporting that the room reached 88 degrees with 79% humidity during a July 3rd concert. Port estimated the cost to repair the auditorium’s HVAC at approximately $1.5 million and the loading dock stormwater issues at $125,000, projecting a revenue loss of about $1.9 million for the HCCA budget and an impact on approximately 87,000 patrons.

Daniel Kirby, Executive Director of the Asheville Symphony, testified that the symphony cannot perform in the auditorium because acoustic instruments are sensitive to temperature fluctuations. Kirby described the facility as "like a car with 400,000 miles on it" and noted that moving shows to alternative venues has increased the symphony's artistic costs by about 20% and reduced revenue potential by about 22%. He stated that the organization is currently absorbing these costs by eating through about a third of its cash reserves in one year but cannot continue to do so year over year. Donna Bailey summarized the total financial hit to the community as $3.5 million, combining the repair costs and lost revenue.

Regarding the Special Events Program, John Feldman, Community Events Manager, explained that the new structure is the result of almost five years of consideration. He noted that the 75% discount for nonprofits is now permanently in the fees and charges manual, and the new grant program will be administered by the Asheville Area Arts Council.

Follow-ups

Assistant City Manager Ben Woody agreed to allow staff time to complete a financial analysis and explore options for the Civic Center repairs, stating that the team would look at the financial impacts and potentially bring the findings back to the committee at a future date. Additionally, Ben Woody agreed to incorporate information regarding the timeline and status of the Haywood Page project into the report being prepared by Chris Port, in response to a request from Councilwoman Sage Turner.

Impact

The decisions and discussions at this meeting highlight the urgent need for infrastructure investment in the city’s primary civic venue. The committee’s recommendation to restructure the Special Events Program aims to create a more sustainable and equitable framework for supporting outdoor events, shifting from broad fee waivers to a targeted grant system administered by the Asheville Area Arts Council. Meanwhile, the detailed testimony regarding the Harris Cherokee Center underscores the financial and operational strain that deferred maintenance places on local arts organizations and the broader community, with the committee now tasked with reviewing staff analysis on potential repair options.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches