Planning & Economic Development – June 12, 2023
June 12, 2023 at 4:00 PM
- 1 h 35 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On June 12, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee convened to review the minutes from the previous meeting and discuss three primary agenda items: an annual update from the Downtown Commission, a proposal for the 2024 Special Event Program, and an informational update on the AVL Alliance Unpaved Trails Project.
Key Decisions
The committee’s only formal action was the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting. A motion was made to approve the minutes, and a roll call vote was taken. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman and Chair Sandra Kilgore voted "Aye," resulting in the approval of the minutes. No other members were present to vote.
Regarding the 2024 Special Event Program, the committee did not record a vote. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman stated she was not ready to vote and needed to consult with others. Consequently, the committee agreed to revisit the item at the July 10 meeting to allow for further discussion and to obtain a formal recommendation before it goes to the full City Council. The AVL Alliance Unpaved Trails Project was presented for informational purposes only, and no motion or vote was taken.
Discussion Highlights
Brian Moffitt, Chair of the Downtown Commission, presented an update on the commission’s priorities, including the I-26 corridor project, PAC Square visioning, downtown design guidelines, public safety, and equitable entrepreneurial opportunities. Moffitt described the commission’s role, stating, "We are basically a clearinghouse to the downtown community for council and to council for the downtown community... Our only real authority is in making recommendations to council." He also clarified the commission's stance on the Business Improvement District (BID), noting, "My understanding is that it was actually approved but never implemented... One of the things that I'm hearing... is that they don't want that to happen [as a replacement for city services]. They think that the current clean and safe initiative should be the baseline... We want to be clear on that."
John Philbin, Community Events Manager, proposed phasing out the current "Strategic Event Partnership" program and replacing it with a grant administered by the Asheville Area Arts Council. Philbin stated, "We recommend phasing out the strategic event partnership program and replacing it with a grant to cover eligible city services administered by the Asheville Area Arts Council." The proposal also includes continuing support for the Asheville City Market via an agricultural development agreement and maintaining the 75% nonprofit discount. Deputy City Attorney Jannice Ashley explained the legal rationale for the grant structure, stating, "If the city... is deciding between events and who do we give money to and who don't we... it is essentially elevating a particular message in the public space... It is a First Amendment issue."
Lucy Crown, Transportation Planning Division Manager, provided an informational update on three pilot natural surface trail projects funded by a coalition of nonprofits: Asheville on Bikes, Connect Buncombe, and Pisgah Sorba. The projects are located at Bacote Branch, Azalea Park, and French Broad River West. Crown explained, "Natural surface trails is a fancy word for dirt trails. They can be built quicker and cheaper than paved greenways with minimal environmental impacts." Councilwoman Maggie Ullman responded to the presentation, stating, "I really think assets like this help create quality of life for the community... I think that it's such a quality of life thing. And it's very exciting that we can do this in a way with strong partners who over time have really built up their skills."
Community Input
A public commenter, speaking as the Executive Director of the Asheville City Schools Foundation and a local resident, expressed strong support for the unpaved trails. The commenter highlighted that the trails would provide immediate access to green space for students, families, and teachers, and noted that the existing "In Real Life" bike program at Asheville Middle School would utilize the trails. The commenter also argued that increased foot and bike traffic would help deter encampments and garbage in the area. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman thanked the commenter. No other members or staff provided specific replies to the content of the comment.
Follow-ups
Staff and the committee agreed that the 2024 Special Event Program will return to the Planning & Economic Development Committee at the July 10 meeting. Councilwoman Ullman stated she needs to speak with stakeholders before voting. Staff noted that the Policy, Finance, and HR Committee will also hear the item later in June. The goal is to have both committees provide recommendations before the item goes to the full City Council.
For the AVL Alliance Unpaved Trails Project, staff agreed to seek an easement or appropriate legal document from Asheville City Schools for the Bacote Branch trails, which are on the middle school campus. Staff will seek a certificate of appropriateness from the Historic Resource Commission for the Azalea Park trails, located on the Thomas Wolfe Cabin site. Additionally, staff will seek approval from Duke Energy for the French Broad River West trails. Staff plans to return to the committee in the fall to finalize the use agreement before taking it to City Council for adoption.
Impact
This meeting addressed the structure of city support for local events and the development of new recreational infrastructure. The discussion on the Special Event Program highlights a shift in how the city allocates funds for events, moving from direct partnerships to a grant model administered by the Asheville Area Arts Council to address First Amendment concerns regarding public space. The unpaved trails project represents a low-cost, low-impact approach to expanding green space and connectivity in the city, with specific attention to legal permissions required from school districts, historic preservation boards, and utility companies.
Meeting Video & Transcript