Transit Committee – June 20, 2023
June 20, 2023 at 5:00 PM
- 1 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Transit Committee Meeting Recap: June 20, 2023
The City of Asheville Transit Committee held a virtual meeting on June 20, 2023. A significant procedural limitation defined the session: the committee did not achieve a quorum, as it currently has four active members but requires at least seven to vote on official matters. Consequently, no formal motions were voted on or approved during the meeting. Instead, the discussion focused on operational updates, rider rules, and informal recommendations to the parent body, the Multimodal Transportation Committee (MMTC).
Key Decisions and Recommendations Due to the lack of quorum, the committee was unable to take official action on the draft ART System Rules or the removal of a member for attendance issues. However, members and staff agreed to make informal recommendations to the MMTC. Specifically, they recommended that the MMTC remove members with low attendance and appoint new members to help the Transit Committee achieve a quorum. Additionally, they recommended that the MMTC take up and approve the draft ART System Rules, noting that the Transit Committee’s input had already been incorporated into the final draft. A council member stated she would email the MMTC chair, the MMTC member serving as the Transit Committee liaison, lead staff, and the Council MMTC liaison to convey these recommendations. The removal of a specific member, Philip Becerra, for attendance issues is scheduled for the MMTC on June 28, 2023.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented the most recent draft of the bus system rules, including posters detailing items allowed and not allowed on buses. A committee member requested visual clarification on the rider rules poster to distinguish between motorized (battery-powered) scooters and foot-powered or ADA mobility devices, noting that folded electric scooters can be easily confused with other items. In response, a staff member agreed to add captions to the images to specify "motorized scooter" and ensure translations are provided in Spanish and Russian. Another committee member raised concerns about riders over-stuffing grocery carts with non-grocery items, hindering aisle access. Staff explained that the cart size was a compromise to allow grocery transport without blocking the aisle, but acknowledged that the issue of over-stuffing is left to driver discretion.
Operational updates included the arrival of three new buses, with four more expected in September. Staff noted that they are still working on their low no grant and looking at other options. Regarding staffing, a staff member reported that there are currently 58 drivers and believed the number would be higher before the next meeting. Staff also confirmed that system maps with QR codes and URLs are now installed on all buses. A council member raised concerns about public access to the ridership report on the city website and a potential data error in the RATP Dev report. Staff confirmed that the link to the ridership report on the city website has been fixed to allow public access.
Community Input and Rider Experiences While the transcript summary does not report formal public comment from residents, it details several exchanges between committee members, council members, and staff regarding rider experiences. A council member asked about the clear process for reporting issues at bus stops, such as trash or broken shelters. Staff confirmed that the iRide email and the Asheville app are the main feedback channels, supplemented by phone calls and walk-ins, and noted that bus stop inventory surveys have been sent to subscribers twice in the last six months. Another committee member reported an instance where the app showed a bus arriving in 8 minutes, but it did not move for 15 minutes, and the transit station phone was not answered. Staff explained that they do not run the app but have oversight, and they need specific details of errors to investigate with the app provider (Swiftly) and the bus operator (RATP Dev). They noted that adding a second GPS point via a tablet/router has helped improve coverage. A staff member offered her direct phone number in the chat for riders to call if they cannot reach the station, stating she can check if the bus tablet is logged in and locate the bus.
Follow-Ups Several specific follow-ups were agreed upon during the meeting:
- Staff member Catherine agreed to add captions to the rider rules posters to clarify scooter types and ensure translations.
- Staff member Nicole agreed to ensure all committee members receive a copy of the updated ART System Rules draft, as some members had trouble accessing the attachment.
- Staff member LaShawn agreed to check the specific data point regarding "missed miles" for bus 1802 on May 4th, which a council member flagged as a potential error.
- Council member Kim agreed to send an email to the MMTC leadership and staff outlining the informal recommendations to approve the rules and adjust committee membership.
Impact on Residents This meeting highlights the current operational challenges facing the city’s transit system, particularly the difficulty in achieving a quorum to make formal decisions. For residents, the immediate impact includes improved accessibility to ridership data, as the link on the city website has been fixed. The informal recommendations to the MMTC aim to resolve the quorum issue, which is necessary for the committee to officially approve the new rider rules. These rules, which clarify policies on scooters and grocery carts, will directly affect the daily experience of bus riders once approved by the MMTC. Additionally, the provision of a direct staff contact number for GPS tracking errors offers a new avenue for riders to resolve real-time service issues.
Meeting Video & Transcript