Transit Committee – May 16, 2023
May 16, 2023 at 5:00 PM
- 1 h 16 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Asheville Transit Committee met on May 16, 2023. The meeting was primarily focused on operational updates and draft policy reviews, though the committee was unable to conduct formal business for the majority of the session due to a lack of quorum.
Key Decisions and Quorum Issues The committee did not take any formal votes or pass motions during this meeting because it did not achieve a quorum. Staff noted that one member has missed all meetings since joining, and two others have missed four of the last seven. While a motion was made to recommend the removal of a specific non-attending member to the Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC), a formal vote could not be taken. Instead, staff member Kim agreed to carry an informal recommendation to the MMTC to review attendance and potentially create openings. Additionally, discussions regarding changing the meeting time and the election of the vice chair were postponed to the next meeting due to the lack of quorum.
Discussion Highlights: Rider Rules and Operations Staff presented a draft of the Asheville Regional Transit (ART) rider rules, covering definitions, consequences for violations, and the appeal process. Committee members raised several questions regarding specific policies:
- Animals: Staff confirmed that only service animals are allowed on buses.
- Food and Medical Needs: Concerns were raised about riders with tremors who may struggle with the "no food" rule; staff suggested speaking with the individual offline to understand their specific needs.
- Weapons: Staff noted that current practice for incidents involving firearms or knives is to call the Asheville Police Department. A committee member suggested revisiting the rule to ensure immediate bans for weapons.
- Appeals: Staff explained that appeals are currently handled via phone and in-person meetings at the operations center, often with caseworkers present, addressing concerns about how banned riders can access paperwork if they cannot enter the station.
- Carts: Staff confirmed that compact shopping carts are allowed as long as they do not obstruct aisles or seats.
Staff also provided a status update on the joint transit plan, noting recent presentations to stakeholders and upcoming meetings with city and county partners to discuss the Request for Proposal (RFP) and budget. Regarding the bus fleet, staff reported that loaner buses were returned to Vicinity and that three new diesel buses purchased in February are awaiting tires, with delivery to Asheville expected by the end of May. Committee member Colin noted that 17 of the current buses have over 550,000 miles, emphasizing the need for replacements. He also suggested that a "floating bus stop" could be a future opportunity if budget allowed.
Community Input There were no public comments from residents during the public comment period.
Follow-ups Several staff members and committee members agreed to specific follow-up actions:
- Kim (Staff): Agreed to carry an informal recommendation to the MMTC regarding the attendance of a specific committee member.
- Catherine (Staff): Agreed to work with a committee member on a campaign to inform the public that shopping carts are allowed on buses.
- Catherine (Staff): Agreed to look into adding a step to the appeal process explaining how banned riders can request their reports via email or phone.
- LaShawn/Barry (Staff): Agreed to review the rules regarding battery-powered scooters and wheelchairs to ensure clarity, and to look into the "certain circumstances" clause in the appeal process.
- Amber (Staff): Agreed to research the options for the Transportation Development Authority’s (TDA) 2022 overflow funds to see if any can be directed toward transit.
- Bill Hart (Water Resources Director): Agreed to have maintenance staff look at rusted grab handles and missing stop buttons on buses.
- Joseph (Committee Member): Offered to visit a non-attending member in person to determine their level of interest in serving, pending contact information from staff.
Impact This meeting highlighted significant challenges in committee functionality due to attendance issues, which prevented formal decision-making on leadership and scheduling. However, the session provided clarity on upcoming transit operations, including the imminent arrival of new diesel buses to replace aging vehicles with high mileage. The detailed review of rider rules addresses common passenger concerns regarding safety, accessibility, and property, with staff committing to refine the appeal process and public communication regarding what items are permitted on buses.
Meeting Video & Transcript