Equity & Engagement Committee – June 20, 2023
June 20, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 3 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On June 20, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Equity and Engagement Committee convened to address two primary agenda items: a status update on the Community Reparations Commission and a presentation on the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Inclusive and Accessible Government Project. The meeting focused on improving accessibility for public participation and standardizing meeting formats across city boards and commissions.
Key Decisions
The committee voted on three recommendations regarding the ARPA Inclusive and Accessible Government Project. All three motions were moved by Councilwoman Roney and seconded by Councilwoman Turner, and each passed unanimously with three ayes and zero nays.
First, the committee recommended that all boards and commissions move to hybrid meetings, allowing members to participate in person or virtually, while enabling the public to participate in real-time via phone or Google Meet. Second, the committee recommended that council committee meetings remain virtual, with public participation allowed prior to the meeting or in real-time by telephone. Third, the committee recommended that City Council meetings remain in-person only until all board and commission meetings have transitioned to the hybrid model; once that transition is complete, the committee will revisit the interest in hybrid public participation for City Council meetings.
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion on the Community Reparations Commission, Brenda Mills, Director of Equity and Inclusion, emphasized the need for diverse communication channels to reach the public, stating, "I think it's important to... hit them in all kinds of ways we can in the different ways that we can, just because everybody doesn't go on Facebook or everybody doesn't do Twitter."
Regarding the ARPA project, Councilwoman Roney expressed concern about the consistency of current meeting formats, noting that the current process is "scattered and it makes it hard to tell people what to expect." She suggested that a coordinated list of goals and examples would help clarify expectations. Roney also raised an equity concern regarding the logistical challenges for board members, specifically noting that video participation falls below the priority of addressing deep needs such as childcare costs.
Brad Branham, City Attorney, clarified legal constraints, explaining that there is a specific limitation preventing groups conducting quasi-judicial hearings from meeting in any format other than in person. Consequently, the city has taken the position that those particular bodies will continue to meet in person. Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, acknowledged that the current decentralized approach to board accommodations has not been equitable, stating, "We just have not been very equitable in how that has been interpreted... So something that we acknowledge we need to work on."
Follow-ups
Several staff members agreed to specific follow-up actions during the meeting. Brenda Mills agreed to update information in the "Urban News" and noted that CAIT teams on both city and county levels have been providing recaps of reparations meetings. She also stated that the committee will look at an engagement summit in September or October. Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, agreed to incorporate the question about hybrid meetings for the engagement summit into her presentation. Additionally, Rachel Wood stated that the Department of Equity and Inclusion and the City Clerk’s Office plan to suggest a work plan item for Fiscal Year 24 to return to the Equity and Engagement Committee and the Boards and Commissions Committee regarding accommodations for board and commission members.
Impact
These decisions aim to standardize how the public can engage with city governance by establishing a clear path toward hybrid meetings for advisory bodies while maintaining in-person requirements for quasi-judicial hearings. The shift to hybrid models for boards and commissions is intended to improve accessibility and allow for real-time public participation, addressing previous inconsistencies in how different departments managed their advisory boards.
Meeting Video & Transcript