Equity & Engagement Committee – May 16, 2023
May 16, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 23 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville’s Equity and Engagement Committee met on May 16, 2023, to review updates on three primary agenda items: the city’s legally required disparity study, the status of the Community Reparations Commission (CRC), and the National Community Survey alongside the Neighborhood Matching Grants program. The committee’s only formal action during the session was the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting.
Key Decisions
The committee approved the minutes from the last meeting. Chair Shanika Smith called for a roll call vote, and Councilwoman Kim Roney voted “Aye,” as did Chair Smith. The motion carried. No other motions, votes, or formal approvals were recorded during the meeting.
Discussion Highlights
The committee received an update on the disparity study conducted by Miller 3 Consulting. Dave Miller of the consulting firm stated that the firm intends to release drafts of the findings to the city before the final report is complete. Frank McGowan, Interim Assistant Director of Community and Economic Development, clarified that the study focuses on the city’s contracting and purchasing activities, noting, “What we will be looking at is the city's contracting and purchasing activities. It really is not looking at the activities of NCDOT or other areas where we're collaborating.” McGowan also noted that draft recommendations will be presented to council members in October, with action required to extend the current Asheville business inclusion policy, which sunsets on November 1, 2023, if not extended.
Regarding the Community Reparations Commission, Brenda Mills, Director of the Office of Equity and Inclusion, explained that the office is requesting a temporary moratorium of 30 to 60 days to catch up on research and data requests. She noted that a new full-time temporary staff member from the Buncombe County Library Special Collections would be starting to assist with this work.
The committee also discussed the National Community Survey, which was formerly known as the National Citizen Survey. Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, explained that the name change was intentional to acknowledge that communities are made up of both citizens and non-citizens. Additionally, Christina Israel, Community Engagement Manager, announced that beginning January 1, 2024, the Neighborhood Matching Grants program will move to a rolling application and funding cycle, allowing neighborhoods to apply at any point throughout the year.
Follow-ups
Several staff members and members agreed to specific follow-up actions during the meeting. Frank McGowan confirmed that the team will revisit the timing for when the disparity study drafts will be presented to the committee. Councilwoman Kim Roney stated she would send her preliminary thoughts on survey questions to Dawa Hitch and Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager. Rachel Wood stated that staff will return to the committee with feedback on additional research being conducted by Dawa Hitch and proposed bringing the topic to a future agenda briefing to allow full Council to provide feedback on potential open-ended questions before the August finalization deadline. Dawa Hitch stated that staff will draft questions based on the input received and bring them back to the committee for final approval this summer. Finally, in response to a suggestion from Councilwoman Roney to track geographic equity, Christina Israel stated that staff could add a column to the program dashboard listing geographic areas (North, South, East, West, Central) to show the distribution of grants.
Impact
These discussions provide residents with insight into the city’s ongoing efforts to address economic disparities and support community development. The disparity study update highlights the timeline for policy decisions regarding business inclusion, while the transition of the Neighborhood Matching Grants to a rolling cycle offers a more flexible pathway for neighborhood projects. The updates on the National Community Survey indicate that the city is refining its data collection methods to better reflect the diverse population of Asheville.
Meeting Video & Transcript