Skip to main content

Design Review Committee – June 15, 2023

June 15, 2023 at 12:32 PM

  • 46 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Recap: June 15, 2023

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee met on June 15, 2023, to review project applications and administrative items. The primary focus of the meeting was an informal design review for a new hotel project at 15 North Ann Street, alongside a status update on the formal design review for the 68 Carter Street hotel project.

Key Decisions The committee took three formal votes during the session. First, a motion was made to accept the minutes from the previous meeting as written; the motion passed unanimously. Second, a motion was made to continue the 68 Carter Street application to the July 20, 2023 meeting; this motion also passed unanimously. Finally, a motion to adjourn the meeting was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.

Discussion Highlights The bulk of the meeting centered on the informal design review for the 15 North Ann Street hotel. Staff provided context on the site’s complex infrastructure, including a historic right-of-way, the nearby Sycamore Temple, and overhead utilities, noting that the fire department is working with the applicant to bury lines to allow for larger street trees. The applicant’s team from ODA Architecture presented site plans and renderings, which sparked significant debate regarding the building’s design.

Committee members expressed concern that the Ann Street elevation appeared "suburban" or "institutional," lacking the detailed articulation seen on the Carter Street side. One member stated, "It looks like a little suburban building... It looks like something at Ridgefield," while another added, "It feels more like a suburban off-the-highway project than like middle of the city." Specific criticism was directed at the "double horizontal banding" on the lower level, which was questioned for its consistency with the rest of the building’s design language. Members also noted that the site plan appeared to be a "minimal compliance plan" with limited pedestrian amenities compared to the architectural renderings, requesting more context at the street level.

A major point of discussion involved stormwater management. Members highlighted that the project would increase impervious surface from approximately 70% to 93%, impacting a local stormwater system that drains into a polluted stream. One member emphasized the severity of the issue, stating, "All the water coming off this, going down to Patton, goes straight in to the second most polluted stream in Buncombe County... I really need to see these things implemented... Otherwise, it's just, you know, it's a no-go." The committee urged the applicant to implement innovative techniques, such as green roofs, in accordance with the City’s Downtown Design Guidelines, with one member urging, "Read the design guidelines... It's very important that you guys read those design guidelines... We're looking for you to implement those in a substantial way, and not by adding three trees."

Additionally, the potential conversion of Ann Street and Carter Street to one-way traffic was raised. Staff indicated this was under consideration by the City, with a potential configuration of Ann Street northbound and Carter Street southbound to facilitate right turns. A committee member suggested, "I think that there's huge benefit for the residents and your customers with having potentially these streets turned one way... I think that would be an important thing to consider... to bring it in front of traffic engineering."

Follow-ups The architectural team, represented by Matt Gower and Wendy Finnellan of ODA Architecture, stated they would "take another pass" at the Ann Street elevation to address the proportionality and datum issues raised by the committee. They also acknowledged the need to add more "layering" and texture to the design to avoid a suburban feel. Staff member Clay Mitchell indicated they would provide the Downtown Design Guidelines to the applicant if they did not have a copy. The committee noted that they would likely need to modify their submittal requirements for downtown projects to explicitly include streetscape views in future reviews.

Impact This meeting is significant for residents as it addresses the development of a new hotel in the downtown core, specifically regarding its impact on the local environment and streetscape. The committee’s focus on stormwater management highlights concerns about the health of local waterways, while the discussion on facade design and pedestrian amenities reflects an effort to ensure new construction aligns with the character of the downtown area. The potential shift to one-way traffic on Ann and Carter Streets is also a key consideration for local residents and businesses, as it may affect daily travel and customer access.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches