Skip to main content

Design Review Committee – May 18, 2023

May 18, 2023 at 12:29 PM

  • 3 h 33 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: May 18, 2023

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee (DRC) convened on May 18, 2023, to review development projects within the city’s designated design review areas, including the Downtown, Riverfront, and Hotel Overlay districts. The meeting was chaired by Christina Roush (Formerly Booher). Staff members present included Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, and Clay Mitchell, Development Liaison. The committee began by unanimously approving the minutes from the April 2023 meeting.

The committee reviewed four primary projects. The first was an 8-story mixed-use building at 68 Carter Street, which includes 115 hotel rooms, 24 residential units, and ground-floor commercial space. This "Level 2" hotel project seeks to bypass City Council approval via the hotel incentive program, requiring a positive DRC recommendation. Discussion focused heavily on stormwater management and heat island effects. While the applicant added street trees and perimeter plantings, members debated the efficacy of green roofs in a dense downtown context with impaired infrastructure. Members expressed concern that the streetscape design, particularly along Ann Street, relied too heavily on minimum compliance with concrete sidewalks and lacked engaging pedestrian elements. Although the committee generally praised the architectural revisions to the building’s massing and materials, a motion was made to recommend denial because the landscaping and stormwater measures did not meet the higher standards of the Downtown Design Guidelines. Before a final vote on this motion, the applicant requested a continuance to revise the plans. The committee voted to continue the project to the June 15, 2023 meeting.

The second project, located at 226 Hilliard Avenue, involves the adaptive reuse of an existing building while preserving the historic Hayes & Lunsford building. This "Level 2" project is under mandatory review with voluntary compliance. Staff highlighted the use of a rain garden in the central courtyard and pervious pavers to manage stormwater, which eliminates the need for an underground detention system. The applicant agreed to a condition to replace impervious surfaces with pervious or landscaped areas between the 10-foot sidewalk and the building. Discussion centered on "grounding" the building, which appeared to float due to the steep topography, with members suggesting the extension of vertical elements to the ground level. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the project, subject to specific recommendations including reviewing the screening of rooftop mechanicals, balancing seasonal types in the landscape design, and retaining the rain garden and pervious paving.

The third project, a Level 1 development at 130 Biltmore Avenue, involves a new two- and three-story commercial and caretaker residence set into the slope behind an existing historic building. The review addressed the building’s rear access, parking, and its relationship to the existing surface lot. A motion was made to recommend approval of the project as presented, finding it meets the intent of the downtown design guidelines. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously.

The final item was Project Aspire, a large-scale, multi-phase conceptual master plan of approximately 1 million square feet located on both sides of the First Baptist Church. The review focused on massing, height, phasing, and the process for future conditional zoning. A staff member explained that the project would eventually be approved by City Council for conditional zoning, with future phases returning to the DRC for mandatory compliance to avoid further City Council amendments. A member noted that the project would be the tallest building downtown, which is "without precedent." The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the conceptual design, subject to conditions that include integrating green stormwater infrastructure, protecting trees, considering pedestrian scale along Central, College, and Charlotte streets, and developing a relationship with the East End Valley neighborhood to mitigate construction impacts.

Regarding community input, staff noted that online public comments were received for the 68 Carter Street project, primarily concerning construction impacts on neighboring businesses and the local community. For 226 Hilliard Avenue, the chair noted one online comment stating that the UDO does not allow the building to come in that far from the front setback; a staff member responded that such a change would not be in compliance with the UDO. For 130 Biltmore Avenue, the chair noted there were no online comments. For Project Aspire, the chair noted one online comment regarding Charlotte Street conditions, which he believed had been addressed in the presentation. No in-person public comments were recorded for any of the items.

Several follow-up actions were identified. For 226 Hilliard Avenue, a staff member stated that if the applicant is not screening rooftop mechanicals as required, it could be seen as a zoning violation and an enforcement matter, and staff should catch this during the final TRC submission review or final zoning inspection. A member suggested "punching up" the condition regarding screening of rooftop mechanicals so it is considered as the project moves through the process. For Project Aspire, staff is working on scheduling a special meeting for June 21st for the Planning and Zoning Commission to review the project conditions. Staff and members agreed that the project should be bound by the downtown design guidelines as of the date of the application, rather than any future amendments, and this will be part of the project conditions. Additionally, a traffic impact analysis is required, as a preliminary trip generation analysis showed a full study is needed.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches